M S Lee1, M H Pittler, B-C Shin, E Ernst. 1. Complementary Medicine, Peninsula Medical School, Universities of Exeter & Plymouth, 25 Victoria Park Road, Exeter, EX2 4NT, UK. myeong.lee@pms.ac.uk
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Tai chi may have beneficial effects with respect to balance, falls and non-vertebral fractures. The purpose of this systematic review was to evaluate evidence from controlled clinical trials testing the effectiveness of tai chi for osteoporosis. METHODS: Systematic searches were conducted on 20 electronic databases. The outcome measures considered for inclusion were changes in bone parameters. RESULTS: Five randomized clinical trials (RCTs) and two controlled clinical trials (CCT) met all inclusion criteria. In postmenopausal women, one RCT found tai chi to be superior for loss of bone mineral density (BMD) compared with sedentary lifestyle, while two other RCTs found no differences between tai chi and exercises or calcium supplementation for BMD. The meta-analysis showed no significant effect of tai chi on BMD change at the spine compared with no treatment in postmenopausal women. One RCT failed to show favorable effects of tai chi compared with resistance training (RT) for total hip BMD in elderly women. A further RCT compared tai chi with RT on bone metabolism and reported favorable effects compared with RT in the elderly. CONCLUSION: The evidence for tai chi in the prevention or treatment of osteoporosis is not convincing. More rigorous research seems warranted.
INTRODUCTION: Tai chi may have beneficial effects with respect to balance, falls and non-vertebral fractures. The purpose of this systematic review was to evaluate evidence from controlled clinical trials testing the effectiveness of tai chi for osteoporosis. METHODS: Systematic searches were conducted on 20 electronic databases. The outcome measures considered for inclusion were changes in bone parameters. RESULTS: Five randomized clinical trials (RCTs) and two controlled clinical trials (CCT) met all inclusion criteria. In postmenopausal women, one RCT found tai chi to be superior for loss of bone mineral density (BMD) compared with sedentary lifestyle, while two other RCTs found no differences between tai chi and exercises or calcium supplementation for BMD. The meta-analysis showed no significant effect of tai chi on BMD change at the spine compared with no treatment in postmenopausal women. One RCT failed to show favorable effects of tai chi compared with resistance training (RT) for total hip BMD in elderly women. A further RCT compared tai chi with RT on bone metabolism and reported favorable effects compared with RT in the elderly. CONCLUSION: The evidence for tai chi in the prevention or treatment of osteoporosis is not convincing. More rigorous research seems warranted.
Authors: Chwan-Li Shen; James S Williams; Ming-Chien Chyu; Robert L Paige; Allen L Stephens; Katherine B Chauncey; Fiona R Prabhu; Lee T Ferris; James K Yeh Journal: Am J Chin Med Date: 2007 Impact factor: 4.667
Authors: Michael Pfeifer; Mehrsheed Sinaki; Piet Geusens; Steven Boonen; Elisabeth Preisinger; Helmut W Minne Journal: J Bone Miner Res Date: 2004-05-10 Impact factor: 6.741
Authors: Mehrsheed Sinaki; Michael Pfeifer; Elisabeth Preisinger; Eiji Itoi; René Rizzoli; Steven Boonen; Piet Geusens; Helmut W Minne Journal: Curr Osteoporos Rep Date: 2010-09 Impact factor: 5.096
Authors: Peter M Wayne; Julie E Buring; Roger B Davis; Ellen M Connors; Paolo Bonato; Benjamin Patritti; Mary Fischer; Gloria Y Yeh; Calvin J Cohen; Danette Carroll; Douglas P Kiel Journal: BMC Musculoskelet Disord Date: 2010-03-01 Impact factor: 2.362
Authors: Luke J Peppone; Karen M Mustian; Michelle C Janelsins; Oxana G Palesh; Randy N Rosier; Kenneth M Piazza; Jason Q Purnell; Tom V Darling; Gary R Morrow Journal: Clin Breast Cancer Date: 2010-06 Impact factor: 3.225
Authors: Peter M Wayne; Douglas P Kiel; Julie E Buring; Ellen M Connors; Paolo Bonato; Gloria Y Yeh; Calvin J Cohen; Chiara Mancinelli; Roger B Davis Journal: BMC Complement Altern Med Date: 2012-01-30 Impact factor: 3.659