BACKGROUND: Research on the accuracy and precision of noninvasive methods of measuring body temperature is equivocal. OBJECTIVES: To determine accuracy and precision of oral, ear-based, temporal artery, and axillary temperature measurements compared with pulmonary artery temperature. METHODS: Repeated-measures design conducted for 6 months. Sequential temperature measurements on the same side of the body were obtained within 1 minute, with measurements repeated 3 times at 20-minute intervals. Accuracy, precision, and confidence limits were analyzed. RESULTS: In 60 adults with cardiopulmonary disease and a pulmonary artery catheter, mean pulmonary artery temperature was 37.1 degrees C (SD 0.6 degrees C, range 35.3 degrees C-39.4 degrees C). Mean (SD) offset from pulmonary artery temperature (with the mean reflecting accuracy and SD reflecting precision) and confidence limits were 0.09 degrees C (0.43 degrees C) and -0.75 degrees C to 0.93 degrees C for oral measurements, -0.36 degrees C (0.56 degrees C) and -1.46 degrees C to 0.74 degrees C for ear measurements, -0.02 degrees C (0.47 degrees C) and -0.92 degrees C to 0.88 degrees C for temporal artery measurements, and 0.23 degrees C (0.44 degrees C) and -0.64 degrees C to 1.12 degrees C for axillary measurements. Percentage of pairs with differences greater than +/-0.5 degrees C was 19% for oral, 49% for ear, 20% for temporal artery, and 27% for axillary measurements. Intubation increased oral measurements compared with pulmonary artery temperatures (mean difference 0.3 degrees C, SD 0.3 degrees C, P = .001). CONCLUSIONS: Oral and temporal artery measurements were most accurate and precise. Axillary measurements underestimated pulmonary artery temperature. Ear measurements were least accurate and precise. Intubation affected the accuracy of oral measurements; diaphoresis and airflow across the face may affect temporal artery measurements.
BACKGROUND: Research on the accuracy and precision of noninvasive methods of measuring body temperature is equivocal. OBJECTIVES: To determine accuracy and precision of oral, ear-based, temporal artery, and axillary temperature measurements compared with pulmonary artery temperature. METHODS: Repeated-measures design conducted for 6 months. Sequential temperature measurements on the same side of the body were obtained within 1 minute, with measurements repeated 3 times at 20-minute intervals. Accuracy, precision, and confidence limits were analyzed. RESULTS: In 60 adults with cardiopulmonary disease and a pulmonary artery catheter, mean pulmonary artery temperature was 37.1 degrees C (SD 0.6 degrees C, range 35.3 degrees C-39.4 degrees C). Mean (SD) offset from pulmonary artery temperature (with the mean reflecting accuracy and SD reflecting precision) and confidence limits were 0.09 degrees C (0.43 degrees C) and -0.75 degrees C to 0.93 degrees C for oral measurements, -0.36 degrees C (0.56 degrees C) and -1.46 degrees C to 0.74 degrees C for ear measurements, -0.02 degrees C (0.47 degrees C) and -0.92 degrees C to 0.88 degrees C for temporal artery measurements, and 0.23 degrees C (0.44 degrees C) and -0.64 degrees C to 1.12 degrees C for axillary measurements. Percentage of pairs with differences greater than +/-0.5 degrees C was 19% for oral, 49% for ear, 20% for temporal artery, and 27% for axillary measurements. Intubation increased oral measurements compared with pulmonary artery temperatures (mean difference 0.3 degrees C, SD 0.3 degrees C, P = .001). CONCLUSIONS: Oral and temporal artery measurements were most accurate and precise. Axillary measurements underestimated pulmonary artery temperature. Ear measurements were least accurate and precise. Intubation affected the accuracy of oral measurements; diaphoresis and airflow across the face may affect temporal artery measurements.
Authors: Dario B Rodrigues; Paolo F Maccarini; Sara Salahi; Tiago R Oliveira; Pedro J S Pereira; Paulo Limao-Vieira; Brent W Snow; Doug Reudink; Paul R Stauffer Journal: IEEE Trans Biomed Eng Date: 2014-04-15 Impact factor: 4.538
Authors: Nishant Verma; Iman Haji-Abolhassani; Suhas Ganesh; Jesus Vera-Aguilera; Jonas Paludo; Roxana Heitz; Svetomir N Markovic; Kimary Kulig; Atiyeh Ghoreyshi Journal: IEEE J Transl Eng Health Med Date: 2021-07-19 Impact factor: 3.316
Authors: Henry T Stelfox; Sharon E Straus; William A Ghali; John Conly; Kevin Laupland; Adriane Lewin Journal: BMC Anesthesiol Date: 2010-08-12 Impact factor: 2.217
Authors: Paul R Stauffer; Brent W Snow; Dario B Rodrigues; Sara Salahi; Tiago R Oliveira; Doug Reudink; Paolo F Maccarini Journal: Neuroradiol J Date: 2014-02-24
Authors: Daniel J Niven; Kevin B Laupland; Alexis Tabah; Aurélien Vesin; Jordi Rello; Despoina Koulenti; George Dimopoulos; Jan de Waele; Jean-Francois Timsit Journal: Crit Care Date: 2013-12-10 Impact factor: 9.097