OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the comparative efficacy of low dose daily versus alternate day plasma exchange in patients with severe myasthenia. METHODS:Thirty three patients with myasthenia gravis (Osserman's stage II b and III) were randomized to receive alternate day (n = 17) or daily low dose plasma exchange (n = 16). Plasma exchange were carried on each patient, number of exchanges varying subject to their requirements and 20-25 ml/kg plasma was removed during each session. Myasthenia gravis disease scale (MGDS) score was evaluated before and after the procedure. Time to wean off ventilator, removal of nasogastric tube and total duration of hospital stay were also assessed. RESULTS: There was no statistically significant difference between daily vs. alternate day group with regards to change in MGDS score, percentage change in MGDS score, and complication rates. A decreased hospital stay was observed in patients on daily plasma exchange which almost reached statistical significance. CONCLUSION: We conclude from our study that daily and alternate day plasma exchange are similar in their efficacy and complication rates, however the daily schedule could be a preferred modality due to decreased hospital stay.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the comparative efficacy of low dose daily versus alternate day plasma exchange in patients with severe myasthenia. METHODS: Thirty three patients with myasthenia gravis (Osserman's stage II b and III) were randomized to receive alternate day (n = 17) or daily low dose plasma exchange (n = 16). Plasma exchange were carried on each patient, number of exchanges varying subject to their requirements and 20-25 ml/kg plasma was removed during each session. Myasthenia gravis disease scale (MGDS) score was evaluated before and after the procedure. Time to wean off ventilator, removal of nasogastric tube and total duration of hospital stay were also assessed. RESULTS: There was no statistically significant difference between daily vs. alternate day group with regards to change in MGDS score, percentage change in MGDS score, and complication rates. A decreased hospital stay was observed in patients on daily plasma exchange which almost reached statistical significance. CONCLUSION: We conclude from our study that daily and alternate day plasma exchange are similar in their efficacy and complication rates, however the daily schedule could be a preferred modality due to decreased hospital stay.
Authors: R Mantegazza; E Bruzzone; B Regi; D Peluchetti; M Marconi; G Sirchia; V Borroni; F Cornelio Journal: Int J Artif Organs Date: 1987-09 Impact factor: 1.595
Authors: C Antozzi; M Gemma; B Regi; E Berta; P Confalonieri; D Peluchetti; R Mantegazza; F Baggi; M Marconi; F Fiacchino Journal: J Neurol Date: 1991-04 Impact factor: 4.849