Ailsa A Welch1, Sheila A Bingham, Jonathan Reeve, K T Khaw. 1. Department of Public Health and Primary Care, University of Cambridge, Strangeways Site, Cambridge, United Kingdom. ailsa.welch@phpc.cam.ac.uk
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Dietary patterns that promote mild metabolic acidosis may have a negative effect on bone density. OBJECTIVE: We investigated the relation between a measure of dietary acid-base load, potential renal acid load (PRAL), and calcaneal broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA) after adjustment for confounders and also compared the results with different estimates of acid-base load. DESIGN: A cross-sectional study was conducted in 14 563 men and women aged 42-82 y living in Norfolk, United Kingdom, in which measures of calcaneal BUA and dietary PRAL were estimated by using the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition Norfolk (EPIC-Norfolk) food-frequency questionnaire. RESULTS: A more acidic dietary intake (high PRAL) was significantly associated with lower calcaneal BUA in women but not in men; there was a difference of approximately 2% in BUA between the highest and lowest quintiles of PRAL, independent of age, body mass index, smoking habit, physical activity, diagnosed osteoporosis, and history of fracture, and (in women) hormone replacement therapy. No relation was observed between history of fracture or incident fracture and PRAL. Those with the greatest PRAL had higher intakes of meat, fish, eggs, and cereal and cereal products and lower intakes of fruit and vegetables, tea, and coffee. CONCLUSION: PRAL was inversely associated with bone ultrasound measures in women, but the magnitude of the association was relatively small compared with other known risk factors. Further longitudinal studies are required to establish whether, in the long term, these small effects are important in overall fracture risk in populations.
BACKGROUND: Dietary patterns that promote mild metabolic acidosis may have a negative effect on bone density. OBJECTIVE: We investigated the relation between a measure of dietary acid-base load, potential renal acid load (PRAL), and calcaneal broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA) after adjustment for confounders and also compared the results with different estimates of acid-base load. DESIGN: A cross-sectional study was conducted in 14 563 men and women aged 42-82 y living in Norfolk, United Kingdom, in which measures of calcaneal BUA and dietary PRAL were estimated by using the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition Norfolk (EPIC-Norfolk) food-frequency questionnaire. RESULTS: A more acidic dietary intake (high PRAL) was significantly associated with lower calcaneal BUA in women but not in men; there was a difference of approximately 2% in BUA between the highest and lowest quintiles of PRAL, independent of age, body mass index, smoking habit, physical activity, diagnosed osteoporosis, and history of fracture, and (in women) hormone replacement therapy. No relation was observed between history of fracture or incident fracture and PRAL. Those with the greatest PRAL had higher intakes of meat, fish, eggs, and cereal and cereal products and lower intakes of fruit and vegetables, tea, and coffee. CONCLUSION: PRAL was inversely associated with bone ultrasound measures in women, but the magnitude of the association was relatively small compared with other known risk factors. Further longitudinal studies are required to establish whether, in the long term, these small effects are important in overall fracture risk in populations.
Authors: Robert R McLean; Ning Qiao; Kerry E Broe; Katherine L Tucker; Virginia Casey; L Adrienne Cupples; Douglas P Kiel; Marian T Hannan Journal: J Nutr Date: 2011-02-02 Impact factor: 4.798
Authors: C E Neville; I S Young; S E C M Gilchrist; M C McKinley; A Gibson; J D Edgar; J V Woodside Journal: Osteoporos Int Date: 2013-05-29 Impact factor: 4.507