R E B Taylor1, A J Cant, J E Clark. 1. Medical School, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE2 4HH.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Assays based on interferon gamma (IFNgamma) are an exciting new development for screening for latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) in adults, but there are limited data on their effectiveness in children. Nevertheless new National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines recommend their use when screening paediatric tuberculosis (TB) contacts. We evaluated the potential effect of the new NICE guidelines on current paediatric practice. DESIGN: Children screened for TB who had had an IFNgamma assay performed (QuantiFERON-TB Gold (QFG)) were included. Actual outcomes from existing guidelines were compared with those that would have been obtained using NICE guidelines. RESULTS: QFG assays were performed on 120 children, 103 as part of TB contact tracing. Six of the 120 (5%) were QFG positive, and seven of the 120 (6%) were indeterminate. Where both Mantoux and QFG results were available, these agreed in 62/104 (60%) of cases. QFG tests were more likely to correlate with a negative Mantoux (98% agreement) than with a positive Mantoux (11% agreement). Management outcomes differed for 23/103 children seen as part of TB contact tracing. Only one (1%) of these had an indeterminate QFG result. 17 (85%) fewer children would have been given LTBI treatment (chemoprophylaxis) and two (2%) children with possible TB would not have been identified using NICE guidelines. CONCLUSION: New NICE guidelines for the use of IFNgamma-based tests for TB screening will reduce the number of children treated for presumed LTBI. Long-term prospective studies are needed to determine the number of children with positive Mantoux tests but negative IFNgamma results who are not given LTBI treatment yet later develop TB.
OBJECTIVE: Assays based on interferon gamma (IFNgamma) are an exciting new development for screening for latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) in adults, but there are limited data on their effectiveness in children. Nevertheless new National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines recommend their use when screening paediatric tuberculosis (TB) contacts. We evaluated the potential effect of the new NICE guidelines on current paediatric practice. DESIGN:Children screened for TB who had had an IFNgamma assay performed (QuantiFERON-TB Gold (QFG)) were included. Actual outcomes from existing guidelines were compared with those that would have been obtained using NICE guidelines. RESULTS: QFG assays were performed on 120 children, 103 as part of TB contact tracing. Six of the 120 (5%) were QFG positive, and seven of the 120 (6%) were indeterminate. Where both Mantoux and QFG results were available, these agreed in 62/104 (60%) of cases. QFG tests were more likely to correlate with a negative Mantoux (98% agreement) than with a positive Mantoux (11% agreement). Management outcomes differed for 23/103 children seen as part of TB contact tracing. Only one (1%) of these had an indeterminate QFG result. 17 (85%) fewer children would have been given LTBI treatment (chemoprophylaxis) and two (2%) children with possible TB would not have been identified using NICE guidelines. CONCLUSION: New NICE guidelines for the use of IFNgamma-based tests for TB screening will reduce the number of children treated for presumed LTBI. Long-term prospective studies are needed to determine the number of children with positive Mantoux tests but negative IFNgamma results who are not given LTBI treatment yet later develop TB.
Authors: Marsha Feske; Rodolfo J Nudelman; Miguel Medina; Justin Lew; Manisha Singh; Jacob Couturier; Edward A Graviss; Dorothy E Lewis Journal: Clin Vaccine Immunol Date: 2008-08-27
Authors: Shahla Riazi; Barbara Zeligs; Henry Yeager; Stephen M Peters; German A Benavides; Onorina Di Mita; Joseph A Bellanti Journal: Allergy Asthma Proc Date: 2012 May-Jun Impact factor: 2.587
Authors: Noëmi R Meier; Thomas Volken; Marc Geiger; Ulrich Heininger; Marc Tebruegge; Nicole Ritz Journal: Front Pediatr Date: 2019-05-29 Impact factor: 3.418
Authors: Philip C Hill; Dolly J Jackson-Sillah; Annette Fox; Roger H Brookes; Bouke C de Jong; Moses D Lugos; Ifedayo M Adetifa; Simon A Donkor; Alex M Aiken; Stephen R Howie; Tumani Corrah; Keith P McAdam; Richard A Adegbola Journal: PLoS One Date: 2008-01-02 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Tom G Connell; Nicole Ritz; Georgia A Paxton; Jim P Buttery; Nigel Curtis; Sarath C Ranganathan Journal: PLoS One Date: 2008-07-09 Impact factor: 3.240