BACKGROUND: The severity of rhinoconjunctivitis is typically monitored by means of nasal provocation tests (NPTs), where the nasally applied allergens trigger symptoms that are recorded using a scoring system. However, NPTs are time-consuming and stressful for patients; therefore, recording of symptoms during natural allergen exposure on visual analog scales (VASs) is increasingly being used in clinical trials. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate (1) the correlation between VAS symptom recording by patients during natural allergen exposure and symptom scoring by the physician during the NPT and (2) the possibility of replacing the more laborious and distressing allergen provocation tests with the more patient-friendly VAS. METHODS: A total of 119 patients with allergic rhinitis due to grass pollen were enrolled in the study between June 20, 2001, and January 31, 2002. Patients reported the severity of different seasonal symptoms on a VAS and underwent a NPT. RESULTS: No significant correlations between VAS and NPT scores were found. However, all the correlation coefficients between the symptom scores from the NPT and the corresponding symptom scores from the VAS were much higher for the female than the male subgroup. CONCLUSIONS: The VAS does not correlate with the NPT and, therefore, cannot replace the NPT. However, the result may suggest it worthwhile to explore the role of sex in the perception of allergy symptoms.
BACKGROUND: The severity of rhinoconjunctivitis is typically monitored by means of nasal provocation tests (NPTs), where the nasally applied allergens trigger symptoms that are recorded using a scoring system. However, NPTs are time-consuming and stressful for patients; therefore, recording of symptoms during natural allergen exposure on visual analog scales (VASs) is increasingly being used in clinical trials. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate (1) the correlation between VAS symptom recording by patients during natural allergen exposure and symptom scoring by the physician during the NPT and (2) the possibility of replacing the more laborious and distressing allergen provocation tests with the more patient-friendly VAS. METHODS: A total of 119 patients with allergic rhinitis due to grass pollen were enrolled in the study between June 20, 2001, and January 31, 2002. Patients reported the severity of different seasonal symptoms on a VAS and underwent a NPT. RESULTS: No significant correlations between VAS and NPT scores were found. However, all the correlation coefficients between the symptom scores from the NPT and the corresponding symptom scores from the VAS were much higher for the female than the male subgroup. CONCLUSIONS: The VAS does not correlate with the NPT and, therefore, cannot replace the NPT. However, the result may suggest it worthwhile to explore the role of sex in the perception of allergy symptoms.