Frank R Lichtenberg1. 1. Graduate School of Business, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027, USA. frank.lichtenberg@columbia.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To test the hypothesis that, ceteris paribus, people using newer, or later vintage drugs will be in better health, and will therefore be less likely to be admitted to hospitals and nursing homes, by examining the effect of pharmaceutical innovation on the utilisation of hospital and long-term care by elderly Americans during 1997-2003. DESIGN: An estimation of difference-in-differences models of hospital discharge rates using longitudinal state-level data on 12 states. Data on the utilisation of over 43 000 products, by state and year, were obtained from state Medicaid agencies. The extent of utilisation of new drugs in the Medicaid programme is strongly correlated with the extent of utilisation of new drugs in general. PATIENTS OR STUDY PARTICIPANTS: All elderly residents of 12 states during the period 1997-2003. INTERVENTION: The relative utilisation of new and old drugs. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Discharges per elderly individual, discharges to nursing homes per elderly individual, and inpatient deaths per elderly individual. RESULTS: States that had larger increases in drug vintage had smaller increases in the number of hospital discharges per elderly individual. They also had smaller increases in the number of hospital discharges to nursing homes and the number of in-hospital deaths per elderly individual. CONCLUSIONS: Even the upper-bound estimate of the increase in 2003 drug expenditure attributable to the 1997-2003 increase in drug vintage is lower than the sum of the lowest estimates of the 2003 hospital and nursing home expenditure reductions attributable to the 1997-2003 increase in drug vintage.
OBJECTIVE: To test the hypothesis that, ceteris paribus, people using newer, or later vintage drugs will be in better health, and will therefore be less likely to be admitted to hospitals and nursing homes, by examining the effect of pharmaceutical innovation on the utilisation of hospital and long-term care by elderly Americans during 1997-2003. DESIGN: An estimation of difference-in-differences models of hospital discharge rates using longitudinal state-level data on 12 states. Data on the utilisation of over 43 000 products, by state and year, were obtained from state Medicaid agencies. The extent of utilisation of new drugs in the Medicaid programme is strongly correlated with the extent of utilisation of new drugs in general. PATIENTS OR STUDY PARTICIPANTS: All elderly residents of 12 states during the period 1997-2003. INTERVENTION: The relative utilisation of new and old drugs. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Discharges per elderly individual, discharges to nursing homes per elderly individual, and inpatient deaths per elderly individual. RESULTS: States that had larger increases in drug vintage had smaller increases in the number of hospital discharges per elderly individual. They also had smaller increases in the number of hospital discharges to nursing homes and the number of in-hospital deaths per elderly individual. CONCLUSIONS: Even the upper-bound estimate of the increase in 2003 drug expenditure attributable to the 1997-2003 increase in drug vintage is lower than the sum of the lowest estimates of the 2003 hospital and nursing home expenditure reductions attributable to the 1997-2003 increase in drug vintage.
Authors: Pinar Karaca-Mandic; Jeffrey S McCullough; Mustaqeem A Siddiqui; Holly Van Houten; Nilay D Shah Journal: J Oncol Pract Date: 2011-05 Impact factor: 3.840
Authors: Travis C Porco; Bryan Lewis; Elliot Marseille; Jennifer Grinsdale; Jennifer M Flood; Sarah E Royce Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2006-06-19 Impact factor: 3.295