Franco Benazzi1. 1. Hecker Psychiatry Research Center, and Department of Psychiatry, National Health Service, Forli, Italy. FrancoBenazzi@FBenazzi.it
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Recent studies questioned the current categorical split of mood disorders into bipolar disorders (BP) and depressive disorders (MDD). METHODS: Medline database search of papers from the last 10 years on the categorical-dimensional classification of mood disorders. Various combinations of the following key words were used: mood disorders, bipolar, unipolar, major depressive disorder, spectrum, category/categorical, classification, continuity. Only English language clinical papers were included, review papers were excluded, similar papers selected by quality. The number of papers found was 1,141. The number of papers selected was 109. RESULTS: The continuity/spectrum between BP (mainly BP-II) and MDD was supported by the following findings:(1) high frequency of mixed states (mixed mania, mixed hypomania, mixed depression, i.e. co-occurring depression and noneuphoric manic/hypomanic symptoms) because opposite polarity symptoms in the same episode do not support a hypomania/mania-depression splitting; (2) MDD was the most common mood disorder in BP probands' relatives; (3) no bimodal distribution of distinguishing symptoms between BP and MDD; (4) bipolar signs not uncommon in MDD; (5) many MDD shifting to BP; (6) many lifetime manic/hypomanic symptoms in MDD; (7) correlation between lifetime manic/hypomanic symptoms and MDD symptoms; (8) hypomania factors in MDD; (9) MDD often recurrent; (10) similar cognitive style. The categorical distinction between BP (mainly BP-I) and MDD was supported by the following findings: (1) BP more common in BP probands' relatives; (2) lower age at BP onset; (3) females as common as males in BP-I, more common than males in MDD; (4) BP-I depression more atypical and retarded, MDD depression more sleepless and agitated; (5) BP more recurrent. CONCLUSIONS: Focusing on mood spectrum's extremes (BP-I vs. MDD), a categorical distinction seems supported. Focusing on midway disorders (BP-II and MDD plus bipolar signs), a continuity/spectrum seems supported. Results seem to support both a categorical and a dimensional view of mood disorders. Copyright 2007 S. Karger AG, Basel.
BACKGROUND: Recent studies questioned the current categorical split of mood disorders into bipolar disorders (BP) and depressive disorders (MDD). METHODS: Medline database search of papers from the last 10 years on the categorical-dimensional classification of mood disorders. Various combinations of the following key words were used: mood disorders, bipolar, unipolar, major depressive disorder, spectrum, category/categorical, classification, continuity. Only English language clinical papers were included, review papers were excluded, similar papers selected by quality. The number of papers found was 1,141. The number of papers selected was 109. RESULTS: The continuity/spectrum between BP (mainly BP-II) and MDD was supported by the following findings:(1) high frequency of mixed states (mixed mania, mixed hypomania, mixed depression, i.e. co-occurring depression and noneuphoric manic/hypomanic symptoms) because opposite polarity symptoms in the same episode do not support a hypomania/mania-depression splitting; (2) MDD was the most common mood disorder in BP probands' relatives; (3) no bimodal distribution of distinguishing symptoms between BP and MDD; (4) bipolar signs not uncommon in MDD; (5) many MDD shifting to BP; (6) many lifetime manic/hypomanic symptoms in MDD; (7) correlation between lifetime manic/hypomanic symptoms and MDD symptoms; (8) hypomania factors in MDD; (9) MDD often recurrent; (10) similar cognitive style. The categorical distinction between BP (mainly BP-I) and MDD was supported by the following findings: (1) BP more common in BP probands' relatives; (2) lower age at BP onset; (3) females as common as males in BP-I, more common than males in MDD; (4) BP-I depression more atypical and retarded, MDD depression more sleepless and agitated; (5) BP more recurrent. CONCLUSIONS: Focusing on mood spectrum's extremes (BP-I vs. MDD), a categorical distinction seems supported. Focusing on midway disorders (BP-II and MDD plus bipolar signs), a continuity/spectrum seems supported. Results seem to support both a categorical and a dimensional view of mood disorders. Copyright 2007 S. Karger AG, Basel.
Authors: Michael Maes; Raz Yirmyia; Jens Noraberg; Stefan Brene; Joe Hibbeln; Giulia Perini; Marta Kubera; Petr Bob; Bernard Lerer; Mario Maj Journal: Metab Brain Dis Date: 2008-12-16 Impact factor: 3.584
Authors: Gabriel Oh; Sun-Chong Wang; Mrinal Pal; Zheng Fei Chen; Tarang Khare; Mamoru Tochigi; Catherine Ng; Yeqing A Yang; Andrew Kwan; Zachary A Kaminsky; Jonathan Mill; Cerisse Gunasinghe; Jennifer L Tackett; Irving I Gottesman; Gonneke Willemsen; Eco J C de Geus; Jacqueline M Vink; P Eline Slagboom; Naomi R Wray; Andrew C Heath; Grant W Montgomery; Gustavo Turecki; Nicholas G Martin; Dorret I Boomsma; Peter McGuffin; Rafal Kustra; Art Petronis Journal: Biol Psychiatry Date: 2014-07-01 Impact factor: 13.382
Authors: Virginia Soria; Erika Martínez-Amorós; Geòrgia Escaramís; Joaquín Valero; Rosario Pérez-Egea; Cecilia García; Alfonso Gutiérrez-Zotes; Dolors Puigdemont; Mònica Bayés; José M Crespo; Lourdes Martorell; Elisabet Vilella; Antonio Labad; Julio Vallejo; Víctor Pérez; José M Menchón; Xavier Estivill; Mònica Gratacòs; Mikel Urretavizcaya Journal: Neuropsychopharmacology Date: 2010-01-13 Impact factor: 7.853
Authors: Ralph Kupka; Anne Duffy; Jan Scott; Jorge Almeida; Vicent Balanzá-Martínez; Boris Birmaher; David J Bond; Elisa Brietzke; Ines Chendo; Benicio N Frey; Iria Grande; Danella Hafeman; Tomas Hajek; Manon Hillegers; Marcia Kauer-Sant'Anna; Rodrigo B Mansur; Afra van der Markt; Robert Post; Mauricio Tohen; Hailey Tremain; Gustavo Vazquez; Eduard Vieta; Lakshmi N Yatham; Michael Berk; Martin Alda; Flávio Kapczinski Journal: Bipolar Disord Date: 2021-07-23 Impact factor: 5.345