Ashok Nimgade1, Meaghan Sullivan, Rose Goldman. 1. Harvard School of Public Health, Occupational Health Program, Cambirdge Health Alliance, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA. animgade@hms.harvard.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To identify effective lateral epicondylosis interventions and assess the quality of research over time. METHODS: Relevant MEDLINE and EMBASE searches respectively yielded 226 and 187 potential studies. Additional citations were extracted from bibliographies. Thirty controlled trials met inclusion criteria. The Cochrane Collaboration guidelines "quality score" served to rate studies. RESULTS: In the short term (<2 to 3 months) steroid injections and physiotherapy outperformed relative rest. Physiotherapy appears efficacious regardless of time frame. After 3 months, active physiotherapy outperforms injections, but does not appear significantly better than rest. Evidence was neutral or insufficient regarding ultrasound, splinting, or manipulation. Nonsignificant correlations between publication year and study quality score were found. CONCLUSIONS: Overall research quality has not improved with time. Steroid injections appear the most successful short-term intervention for pain relief. Active physiotherapy appears efficacious regardless of time frame.
OBJECTIVE: To identify effective lateral epicondylosis interventions and assess the quality of research over time. METHODS: Relevant MEDLINE and EMBASE searches respectively yielded 226 and 187 potential studies. Additional citations were extracted from bibliographies. Thirty controlled trials met inclusion criteria. The Cochrane Collaboration guidelines "quality score" served to rate studies. RESULTS: In the short term (<2 to 3 months) steroid injections and physiotherapy outperformed relative rest. Physiotherapy appears efficacious regardless of time frame. After 3 months, active physiotherapy outperforms injections, but does not appear significantly better than rest. Evidence was neutral or insufficient regarding ultrasound, splinting, or manipulation. Nonsignificant correlations between publication year and study quality score were found. CONCLUSIONS: Overall research quality has not improved with time. Steroid injections appear the most successful short-term intervention for pain relief. Active physiotherapy appears efficacious regardless of time frame.
Authors: Brooke K Coombes; Leanne Bisset; Luke B Connelly; Peter Brooks; Bill Vicenzino Journal: BMC Musculoskelet Disord Date: 2009-06-24 Impact factor: 2.362