Literature DB >> 17137017

Is health inequality across individuals of moral concern?

Yukiko Asada1.   

Abstract

The history of the documentation of health inequality is long. The way in which health inequality has customarily been documented is by comparing differences in the average health across groups, for example, by sex or gender, income, education, occupation, or geographic region. In the controversial World Health Report 2000, researchers at the World Health Organization criticized this traditional practice and proposed to measure health inequality across individuals irrespective of individuals' group affiliation. They defended its proposal on the moral grounds without clear explanation. In this paper I ask: is health inequality across individuals of moral concern, and, if so, why? Clarification of these questions is crucial for meaningful interpretation of health inequality measured across individuals. Only if there was something morally problematic in health inequality across individuals, its reduction would be good news. Specifically, in this paper I provide three arguments for the moral significance of health inequality across individuals: (a) health is special, (b) health equity plays an important and unique role in the general pursuit of justice, and (c) health inequality is an indicator of general injustice in society. I then discuss three key questions to examine the validity of these arguments: (i) how special is health?, (ii) how good is health as an indicator?, and (iii) what do we mean by injustice? I conclude that health inequality across individuals is of moral interest with the arguments (b) and (c).

Mesh:

Year:  2006        PMID: 17137017     DOI: 10.1007/s10728-006-0008-6

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Health Care Anal        ISSN: 1065-3058


  29 in total

1.  Why reduce health inequalities?

Authors:  A Woodward; I Kawachi
Journal:  J Epidemiol Community Health       Date:  2000-12       Impact factor: 3.710

2.  Working together for equity.

Authors:  D Black
Journal:  Health Econ       Date:  2000-10       Impact factor: 3.046

3.  Policy implications of the gradient of health and wealth.

Authors:  Angus Deaton
Journal:  Health Aff (Millwood)       Date:  2002 Mar-Apr       Impact factor: 6.301

4.  Inequalities in health, inequalities in health care: four generations of discussion about justice and cost-effectiveness analysis.

Authors:  Madison Powers; Ruth Faden
Journal:  Kennedy Inst Ethics J       Date:  2000-06

Review 5.  The concern for equity in health.

Authors:  S Anand
Journal:  J Epidemiol Community Health       Date:  2002-07       Impact factor: 3.710

6.  A note on the decomposition of the health concentration index.

Authors:  Philip M Clarke; Ulf-G Gerdtham; Luke B Connelly
Journal:  Health Econ       Date:  2003-06       Impact factor: 3.046

7.  Class, health and justice.

Authors:  S Marchand; D Wikler; B Landesman
Journal:  Milbank Q       Date:  1998       Impact factor: 4.911

8.  Individual income, income distribution, and self rated health in Japan: cross sectional analysis of nationally representative sample.

Authors:  Kenji Shibuya; Hideki Hashimoto; Eiji Yano
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2002-01-05

Review 9.  Defining equity in health.

Authors:  P Braveman; S Gruskin
Journal:  J Epidemiol Community Health       Date:  2003-04       Impact factor: 3.710

10.  Measuring total health inequality: adding individual variation to group-level differences.

Authors:  Emmanuela Gakidou; Gary King
Journal:  Int J Equity Health       Date:  2002-08-12
View more
  5 in total

1.  A summary measure of health inequalities for a pay-for-population health performance system.

Authors:  Yukiko Asada
Journal:  Prev Chronic Dis       Date:  2010-06-15       Impact factor: 2.830

2.  Response-oriented measuring inequalities in Tehran: second round of UrbanHealth Equity Assessment and Response Tool (Urban HEART-2), concepts and framework.

Authors:  Mohsen Asadi-Lari; Mohammad Reza Vaez-Mahdavi; Soghrat Faghihzadeh; Bahman Cherghian; Alireza Esteghamati; Ali Asghar Farshad; Mehdi Golmakani; Ali-Asghar Haeri-Mehrizi; Hossein Hesari; Naser Kalantari; Mohammad Kamali; Ramin Kordi; Hossein Malek-Afzali; Ali Montazeri; Maziar Moradi-Lakeh; Abbas Motevallian; Ahmad Noorbala; Hossein Raghfar; Emran Razzaghi
Journal:  Med J Islam Repub Iran       Date:  2013-11

Review 3.  Scoping review of the World Health Organization's underlying equity discourses: apparent ambiguities, inadequacy, and contradictions.

Authors:  Michelle M Amri; Geneviève Jessiman-Perreault; Arjumand Siddiqi; Patricia O'Campo; Theresa Enright; Erica Di Ruggiero
Journal:  Int J Equity Health       Date:  2021-03-03

4.  Health inequalities in Ethiopia: modeling inequalities in length of life within and between population groups.

Authors:  Eirik Joakim Tranvåg; Merima Ali; Ole Frithjof Norheim
Journal:  Int J Equity Health       Date:  2013-07-11

5.  Ethics of sharing medical knowledge with the community: is the physician responsible for medical outreach during a pandemic?

Authors:  Rael D Strous; Tami Karni
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2020-09-21       Impact factor: 5.926

  5 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.