David D Pothier1, A A Narula. 1. Department of Otolaryngology, Gloucester Royal Hospital, Gloucester, UK. email@davepothier.com
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a well-established investigation in thyroid disease. Fine needle sampling without aspiration (FNS) is less commonly used but often easier to perform. Both methods have advantages and disadvantages but, as yet, there is no agreement on which method produces better specimens for cytological diagnosis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We undertook a review of the literature and performed a meta-analysis of the results of four cross-over trials. RESULTS: The resulting odds ratio favoured FNS (OR = 0.99; 95% CI 0.88-1.11) but was not statistically significant. A fifth paper not included in the meta-analysis reported results in favour of FNS (P = 0.003). CONCLUSIONS: There is no evidence from the meta-analysis that one method is superior to the other; however, taking into consideration all available evidence, it seems that FNS may be easier to perform and may produce better samples.
INTRODUCTION: Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a well-established investigation in thyroid disease. Fine needle sampling without aspiration (FNS) is less commonly used but often easier to perform. Both methods have advantages and disadvantages but, as yet, there is no agreement on which method produces better specimens for cytological diagnosis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We undertook a review of the literature and performed a meta-analysis of the results of four cross-over trials. RESULTS: The resulting odds ratio favoured FNS (OR = 0.99; 95% CI 0.88-1.11) but was not statistically significant. A fifth paper not included in the meta-analysis reported results in favour of FNS (P = 0.003). CONCLUSIONS: There is no evidence from the meta-analysis that one method is superior to the other; however, taking into consideration all available evidence, it seems that FNS may be easier to perform and may produce better samples.
Authors: Xiaoyun Liu; Lijun Zhu; Zhixiao Wang; Dai Cui; Huanhuan Chen; Ling Wei; Yunsong Wu; Rong Rong; Yan Wu; Qing Yao; Zhihong Zhang; Edmund S Cibas; Erik K Alexander; Tao Yang Journal: Mol Clin Oncol Date: 2015-01-22
Authors: Leo F Tauro; Geover J Lobo; Hilda Fernandes; Celine George; P Sathyamoorthy Aithala; Divakar Shenoy; Prathvi Shetty Journal: Oman Med J Date: 2012-03