E Gappmaier1, W Lake, A G Nelson, A G Fisher. 1. Division of Physical Therapy, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT 84108, USA. eduard.gappmaier@hsc.utah.edu
Abstract
AIM: It has been suggested, that water exercise is less effective than weight-bearing exercise on land for body fat reduction. METHODS: To test this hypothesis 38 middle-aged obese women (25-47% body fat) participated in a 13 weekexercise-diet program to compare the effects of aerobic exercise in water versus walking on land on indices of fat reduction and weight loss changes. Subjects were randomly assigned to 1 of 3 exercise groups: 1) walking on land (WL), 2) swimming (SW) at 27 degrees C water temperature and 3) walking in 29 degrees C water (WW) at the shallow end of a declining pool with the water at navel height. Subjects in the SW group alternated breast-, side-, and backstroke swimming without face immersion. Exercise parameters were kept constant for all three groups. Subjects participated in supervised exercise sessions for 40 min, 4 times a week at 70% of age-predicted maximum heart rate. Subjects were tested before and after the 13-week experimental period. RESULTS: Significant reductions in body weight, (5.9 kg), percent body fat, (3.7%), and skinfold and girth measurements, occurred in all groups. There where no significant differences between groups. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study indicate that there are no differences in the effect of aerobic activities in the water versus weight-bearing aerobic exercise on land on body composition components as long as similar intensity, duration and frequency are used.
RCT Entities:
AIM: It has been suggested, that water exercise is less effective than weight-bearing exercise on land for body fat reduction. METHODS: To test this hypothesis 38 middle-aged obesewomen (25-47% body fat) participated in a 13 week exercise-diet program to compare the effects of aerobic exercise in water versus walking on land on indices of fat reduction and weight loss changes. Subjects were randomly assigned to 1 of 3 exercise groups: 1) walking on land (WL), 2) swimming (SW) at 27 degrees C water temperature and 3) walking in 29 degrees C water (WW) at the shallow end of a declining pool with the water at navel height. Subjects in the SW group alternated breast-, side-, and backstroke swimming without face immersion. Exercise parameters were kept constant for all three groups. Subjects participated in supervised exercise sessions for 40 min, 4 times a week at 70% of age-predicted maximum heart rate. Subjects were tested before and after the 13-week experimental period. RESULTS: Significant reductions in body weight, (5.9 kg), percent body fat, (3.7%), and skinfold and girth measurements, occurred in all groups. There where no significant differences between groups. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study indicate that there are no differences in the effect of aerobic activities in the water versus weight-bearing aerobic exercise on land on body composition components as long as similar intensity, duration and frequency are used.
Authors: Tiago M Barbosa; Daniel A Marinho; Victor M Reis; António J Silva; José A Bragada Journal: J Sports Sci Med Date: 2009-06-01 Impact factor: 2.988