Occurrence of haemolytic Mannheimia spp. in apparently healthy sheep in Norway.

BACKGROUND: The occurrence of Mannheimia species in healthy sheep has only been investigated to a very limited extend since the genus and its five named species were established. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the occurrence of haemolytic Mannheimia species in apparently healthy sheep originating from four sheep flocks in South-Western Norway.
METHODS: Typical beta-haemolytic Pasteurellaceae were isolated from nasal swabs and subsequently subjected to bacteriological examination. A total of 57 Mannheimia isolates were obtained in pure culture. All isolates were genotyped by amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLP) analysis and compared to six reference strains. The 16S rRNA gene sequences of two isolates were also determined.
RESULTS: beta-haemolytic Mannheimia species were isolated from 24% to 64% of the sheep in the four flocks. A total of 26 haemolytic M. ruminalis-like strains were isolated among which, a considerable genetic diversity was found. Eighteen M. glucosida isolates were obtained from three flocks, whereas M. haemolytica was only isolated from two flocks, 16 of them being from only one of the flocks.
CONCLUSION: We demonstrate that a relatively high number of apparently healthy sheep in Norway seem to carry the potentially pathogenic M. haemolytica and M. glucosida in the upper respiratory tract. An unexpectedly high number of haemolytic M. ruminalis-like organisms were also obtained in all four flocks. The usually non-haemolytic M. ruminalis are typically isolated from healthy ruminants. The significance of beta-haemolytic M. ruminalis-like organisms is unknown and should be investigated in a future study.

Background

Mannheimia was proposed for the trehalose-negative [Pasteurella] haemolytica complex including at least seven species, five of which were named [1]. [P.] haemolytica was reclassified as M. haemolytica including the former [P.] haemolytica biogroup 1 and serovars 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14 and 16 while M. glucosida was proposed to include [P.] haemolytica serovar 11, biogroups 3A-H and the β-glucosidase and meso-inositol positive strains of biogroup 9. M. varigena includes the former [P.] haemolytica biogroup 6 and Bisgaard taxon 15 and taxon 36. The former [P.] granulomatis and Bisgaard taxon 20 and [P.] haemolytica biogroup 3J were combined in M. granulomatis. Finally, M. ruminalis was proposed to include the former Bisgaard taxon 18 and [P.] haemolytica biogroup 8D [1]. A novel Mannheimia species was subsequently reported from Australian feedlot cattle [2]. The specificity of serotyping as a diagnostic tool was subsequently investigated by Angen et al. [3,4] who demonstrated that serotyping does not represent a reliable method for identification. The same authors emphasized that extended phenotypic and genetic characterization is necessary for proper identification of these organisms making it difficult to decide which of the present taxa are dealt with in previous studies, based only upon phenotyping and serotyping [5-11].

Most species of Mannheimia are known as opportunistic pathogens [12] and are frequently isolated from asymptomatic carriers [6,9,13]. In sheep, disease caused by Mannheimia species has mainly included pneumonia and septicaemia [13], although isolates have been reported from cases of mastitis and the myocardium and the brain of healthy animals [3].

Due to the above mentioned changes in taxonomy and the impact it may have on the understanding of the aetiology, pathogenesis and epidemiology of these organisms, the present investigation aims at determining the occurrence of haemolytic Mannheimia species in healthy sheep herds from South-Western Norway. The results demonstrated that a relatively high number of apparently healthy sheep in Norway seems to carry the potentially pathogenic M. haemolytica and M. glucosida in the upper respiratory tract. In addition we found an unexpectedly high number of haemolytic M. ruminalis-like organisms in all four flocks.

Materials and methods

Herds and bacterial sampling

A total of 139 adult sheep originating from four herds in Ims, Stave, Kjosavik, and Sandnes, Norway were included in the study which took place during the spring of 2005. Epidemiological relations were not demonstrated among the randomly selected herds. The herd in Ims consisted of 33 adult Texel sheep. Within this herd, a single sheep suffered from pasteurellosis in 2004. A new ram was introduced the same year, but otherwise the flock had had no contact with other sheep. The flock in Stave included 38 adult Norwegian white sheep. Four or five cases of pasteurellosis were observed during 2004. A new ram was introduced to the flock the same year and part of the flock had been grazing with other herds during the summer. The Kjosavik flock consisted of 40 adult Norwegian white sheep and crossbreeds. A single animal suffered from pasteurellosis in 2004. No new animals were introduced to the flock during 2004, but the flock had been grazing in the mountains with other herds during the summer. Finally, the flock in Sandnes included 200 adult sheep of various mixed breeds of Norwegian White Sheep. From this herd, 11 adult sheep and 17 lambs were included in the survey. Though, the herd was grassing with other herds during the summer, pasteurellosis had not been diagnosed in this flock for many years. The tentative diagnosis, pasteurellosis was based on the lesions described by Gilmour and Gilmour [13].

Bilateral nasal swabs were taken using sterile cotton swabs from each animal. The swabs were plated onto 5% ovine blood agar plates (Oxoid) and incubated in 5.8% CO2 for 18–20 hours at 37°C. After incubation, the plates were examined for Pasteurellaceae-like colonies that were greyish or yellowish, and showing a narrow zone of β-haemolysis. A single haemolytic colony was subcultured and tested by Gram-staining, catalase, and oxidase. All strains which proved catalase positive, cytochrome-oxidase positive, Gram-negative and having the typical colony morphology of Pasteurellaceae were stored at -80°C in porous beads (Microbank™, pro-lab diagnostics) and subsequently taken to The Department of Veterinary Pathobiology, The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Copenhagen for further characterization.

Bacterial phenotyping

A total of 57 pure cultures were characterised phenotypically. Isolates were designated I for Ims, S for Stave, K for Kjosavik and only the number from Sandnes (except for C1, also from Sandnes). Phenotypical characters included, colony morphology on blood agar (Tryptose blood agar base [Difco] containing 5% citrated bovine blood), cell morphology observed by phase-contrast microscopy, Gram-staining, 3% KOH test, catalase (3% H2O2) and oxidase (Fluka). Motility was examined by phase-contrast at 37°C, and by inoculation in VL-semisolid medium (Heart Infusion Broth (Difco) added 0. 25% agar) following incubation at 22°C for 24 hours. Catabolism of glucose was examined in Hugh and Leifson's medium (Merck). Urease was tested in Christensen's urea medium (Merck). Indole production was examined by adding Kovac's reagent to a 48 hours old Heart Infusion Broth culture. Production of acid from: L(+)arabinose, D(+)mannose, and trehalose was examined as reported previously [14] while production of α-fucosidase (ONPF) and β-glucosidase (NPG) were determined with Rosco diagnostic tablets according to the manufactures instructions. CAMP-test was performed according to Christie et al. [15].

Bacterial genotyping by AFLP and 16S rRNA sequencing

Isolates classified with species of Mannheimia were subsequently characterized by AFLP and compared with the following reference strains: M. haemolytica NCTC 9380T, M. glucosida P925T and M. ruminalis HPA92T. Furthermore, six strains previously identified as M. ruminalis (HPA90, HPA93, HPA98, HPA109) and M. glucosida (P730, P733) were included [16].

DNA was extracted using a DNA purification kit (Prestospin D Bug, Molzym) according to the manufacturer's instruction. AFLP typing was carried out as reported previously [17]. Briefly, the non-selective BglII primer (FAM-5' GAGTACACTGTCGATCT 3') and the non-selective BspDI primer (5' GTGTACTCTAGTCCGAT 3') were used to amplify the fragments subsequent to restriction digestion and ligation to their corresponding adaptors. Amplification products were detected on an ABI 377 automated sequencer (PE Biosystems). Each lane included an internal-lane size standard labelled with ROX dye (Applied Biosystems) and GeneScan 3.1 fragment analysis software (Applied Biosystems) was used for fragment size determination and pattern analysis. AFLP profiles comprising fragments in the size range 50–500 bp were considered for numerical analysis with the program GelCompar II (Applied Maths, Kortrijk, Belgium). Normalised AFLP fingerprints were compared using the Dice similarity coefficient and clustering analysis was performed by the UPGMA.

16S rRNA gene sequencing included two strains, S9 and 85, representing two of the three main clusters in the M. ruminalis cluster in Fig. 1. PCR amplification was performed according to the standard conditions described by Vogel et al. [18]. Oligonucleotides for both PCR amplification and 16S rRNA sequencing were synthesized according to sequences and positions given in Dewhirst et al. [19] and Paster and Dewhirst [20]. DNA sequencing was performed on the ABI 377 (Applied Biosystems) sequencer with unlabelled primers and the BigDye kit according to protocols described with the Chemistry Guide for automated DNA sequencing (Applied Biosystems). Searches for DNA sequences at NCBI were performed by BLAST [21].

Figure 1

Genetic diversity among the obtained . Dendrogram showing AFLP similarities (Dice coefficient) between the Mannheimia isolates obtained from healthy sheep and the type strains M. haemolytica (NCTC9380T), M. glucosida (P925T) and M. ruminalis (HPA92T). Six strains previously identified as M. ruminalis (HPA90, HPA93, HPA98, HPA109) and M. glucosida (P730, P733) were also included. Isolates obtained in the present study were designated I from Ims, S from Stave, K from Kjosavik and only the number from Sandnes (except C1 also from Sandnes). The vertical dotted line at 90% similarity denotes the cut-off value for a clone.

Results

Based on the phenotypic characters outlined for each Mannheima species in Table 1, the species distribution of isolates obtained from the present investigation is summarized in Table 2. There were found no discrepancies between the phenotypic character demonstrated for present isolates and the ones outlined for the different Mannheimia species by Angen et al. [1]. However, given the considerable genetic diversity among the isolates classifying with M. ruminalis will be referred too, as M. ruminalis-like organisms. Interestingly, all isolates classified with M. ruminalis were β-haemolytic on ovine blood, although this species generally is regarded as non-haemolytic. The M. ruminalis-like organisms were the most prevalent Mannheimia species present in all four flocks.

Table 1

Phenotypic characters used for identification and separation of species investigated.

	M. haemolytica	M. glucosida	M. ruminalis
Gram-staining	-	-	-
Catalase	+	+	+
Oxidase	+	+	d
Motility	-	-	-
Haemolysis on ovine blood	+	+	d
Haemolysis on bovine blood	+	+	-
H&L, glucose	F	F	F
Urease	-	-	-
Indole	-	-	-
D(+)mannose	-	-	-
Trehalose	-	-	-
L(+)arabinose	-	d	-
α-fucosidase	+	+	-
β-glucosidase	-	+	-
CAMP reaction	+/weak	+	-

+: ≥ 90% strains are positive, -: < 10% strains are positive, d: <90 and ≥10 positive, (+): Late positive (3–14 days), F: fermentative [1].

Table 2

Species identified within the four herds investigated.

Farm	Flock size	M. haemolytica	M. ruminalis	M. glucosida	No of sheep affected with pasteurellosis in previous years
Ims	33	-	8	-	1
Stave	38	-	9	3	4/5
Kjosavik	40	16	1	2	1
Sandnes	200 *	2	8	8	0

* (28 sampled)

AFLP typing and cluster analysis revealed two major clusters diverging at a 38% similarity level, one containing isolates classified with M. ruminalis and another containing isolates classified as M. haemolytica and M. glucosida. All 26 isolates of M. ruminalis-like isolates clustered with the type strain and the four additional strains of M. ruminalis included. A considerable genetic diversity was observed within the M. ruminalis cluster. For this reason two isolates (S9 and 85) each representing a subcluster containing the M. ruminalis type strain (HPA92T) and a subcluster including no reference strain, respectively, were characterized by 16S rRNA gene sequencing. The results showed 99.6% and 99.4% similarity between the type strain, M. ruminalis (HPA92T), and the isolates S9 and 85, respectively. A 99.7% 16S rRNA sequence similarity was observed between the isolates S9 and 85. In addition, these isolates showed 96.5% to 98.1% 16S rRNA sequence similarity with the type strains of M. haemolytica, M. glucosida and M. granulomatis, the highest similarity observed between S9 and the M. glucosida type strain.

The genetic diversity of the M. ruminalis-like isolates obtained from the Sandnes flock was considerable while isolates from the three other farms were generally more closely related. Six out of eight isolates of M. ruminalis-like isolates from the flock in Ims were highly related (Fig. 1). Only around 38% similarity was observed between the type strain and the isolates obtained in the present study.

Sixteen out of 40 sheep from the flock in Kjosavik sampled positive for M. haemolytica while only two (77 and C1) sheep out of 28 examined from the flock in Sandnes sampled positive. All 18 M. haemolytica isolates formed a separate AFLP cluster with the type strain of M. haemolytica (NCTC9380T). A total of 13 isolates of M. glucosida were obtained from the flocks in Stave, Kjosavik, and Sandnes. These isolates also formed an AFLP cluster grouping with the type strain (P925T) and the included reference strains (P730 and P733).

Discussion

Previous investigations on the prevalence of [P.] haemolytica have shown a considerable variation. A range between 8.9% and 96.2% of healthy sheep that carry these organisms in the nasal cavity have been reported [6,7,22]. The variation is likely to be caused by several factors including different isolation techniques, misidentification, and seasonal variation. Swabbing of the tonsils and nasal cavity of slaughtered sheep showed that [P.] haemolytica could be isolated from 95% of the tonsils and 64% of the nasopharyngeal swabs [9]. Furthermore, it has been found that the prevalence of [P.] haemolytica in temperate climates varies seasonally with a higher prevalence in spring and early summer [13].

In the present survey, the isolation rate of Mannheimia spp. varied from 24% to 64% in the four herds investigated. However, only a single haemolytic colony on sheep blood agar was subcultured and characterized from each sample. In addition, the nasal cavity was sampled instead of the tonsils which might explain the complete lack of isolation of [P.] trehalosi. In this survey, the sheep were swabbed in May, where the prevalence of Mannheimia spp. was expected to be at its highest. With the exception of the flock in Ims, at least two different species of Mannheimia were isolated in each flock. In addition, six out of eight isolates of M. ruminalis from the flock in Ims were highly related genetically, probably reflecting the fact that this flock has been kept isolated over time. This flock also showed the overall lowest isolation rate of Mannheimia spp.

According to Gilmour and Gilmour [13], [P.] haemolytica (M. haemolytica) is normally associated with pneumonia in cattle and sheep, septicaemia in lambs and mastitis in ewes. These observations have subsequently been supported by Angen et al. [1,4]. However, the present investigation clearly demonstrated that these organisms also can be obtained from the upper respiratory tract of apparently healthy sheep.

M. glucosida seems to be associated with the upper respiratory tract and rumen of sheep, but has also been reported from various lesions [1,4]. M. ruminalis has, so far only been reported from the rumen of sheep and cattle [1,3] and mainly in a non-haemolytic form. However, only relatively few strains are available and considering the results of the present study, it may be questioned whether the non-haemolytic phenotype is general to M. ruminalis or if this merely applies to a sub-population of this species. We feel confident about the classification of the M. ruminalis-like isolates from this investigation as they showed very high 16S rRNA gene similarity to the M. ruminalis type strain (HPA92T) and also clustered with the M. ruminalis strains HPA98 ([P.] haemolytica biogroup 8), HPA90 (Bisgaard taxon 18 biovar 2 (arab+)) and HPA93 and HPA109 (Bisgaard taxon 18 biovar 3 (sorb+)), as demonstrated by AFLP. Except for the haemolytic phenotype of the M. ruminalis-like strains there were no discrepancies to the phenotypic results outlined in Table 1. It has been suggested that the non-haemolytic M. ruminalis have lost virulence factors associated with their pathogenic and phylogenetic ancestors [23]. It could therefore be speculated if the β-haemolytic M. ruminalis-like organisms isolated in the current study represent an intermediate form. Alternatively, there may be different subpopulations, which have adapted to different niches i.e. in the nasal cavity and rumen. Although our study included representatives from both the nasal cavity and the rumen we were not able to demonstrate genetically distinct sub-populations based on the site of isolation. Loss of virulence factors may reflect that these organisms generally have adapted to a broader ecological niche, which is supported by the high genetic diversity demonstrated by AFLP. Consequently, future studies addressing the β-haemolytic phenotype and its genetic background in M. ruminalis will be highly relevant.

Savelkoul et al. [24] found that Klebsiella strains showing a 90–100% fingerprint similarity could be considered as belonging to the same clone. In other studies including Acinetobacter [25] and Gallibacterium anatis [26] the same similarity values have been used to define a clone. Provided that the same value can be used to define clones within species of Mannheimia, it indicated that all flocks investigated have been exposed to several introductions of Mannheimia spp. over time or that several clonal lineages have evolved within each flock.

Conclusion

The present study demonstrates that M. haemolytica, M. glucosida and M. ruminalis-like organisms are commonly found in the upper respiratory tract of healthy sheep. Interestingly, the occurrence of haemolytic M. ruminalis-like isolates was unexpectedly high. This organism has usually been isolated in a non-haemolytic form. The importance of this finding will have to be investigated in future studies, in order to conclude on the biological significance of the different haemolytic/non-haemolytic phenotypes.

Abbreviations

AFLP: Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphisms

UPGMA: Unweighted Pair Group Method with Arithmetic Averages

Competing interests

The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors' contributions

LLP, RLS and TRM took part in all aspects of the investigation including planning, sampling, phenotypic and genotypic characterization and drafting of the manuscript. SS participated in the planning, sampling and initial characterization of the bacterial isolates. MB participated in the planning, phenotypical characterization and drafting of the manuscript. HC did the 16S rRNA sequence alignments. JEO participated in the planning and drafting of the investigation. AMB participated in the genotypical characterization, drafting and revision of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.