Marc D Basson1, Timothy Butler. 1. Department of Surgery, John D. Dingell VA Medical Center and Wayne State University, 4646 John R. Street, Detroit, MI 48201-1932, USA. marc.basson@va.gov
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Operating room (OR) activity transcends single ratios such as cases/room, but weighting multiple inputs and outputs may be arbitrary. Data-envelopment analysis (DEA) is a novel technique by which each facility is analyzed by the weightings that optimize its score. METHODS: We performed DEA analysis of 23 Veterans Health Administration annual OR activity; 87,180 cases were performed, 24 publications generated, and 560 trainee-years of education delivered, in 168 ORs over 166,377 hours by 1,384 full-time equivalents of surgical and anesthesia providers and 523 nonproviders. RESULTS: Varying analyzed parameters produced similar efficiency rankings, with individual differences suggesting possible inefficiencies. We characterized returns to scale for efficient sites, suggesting whether patient flow might be efficiently further increased through these sites. We matched inefficient sites to similar efficient sites for comparison and suggested resource alterations to increase efficiency. CONCLUSIONS: Broader DEA application might characterize OR efficiency more informatively than conventional single-ratio rank ordering.
BACKGROUND: Operating room (OR) activity transcends single ratios such as cases/room, but weighting multiple inputs and outputs may be arbitrary. Data-envelopment analysis (DEA) is a novel technique by which each facility is analyzed by the weightings that optimize its score. METHODS: We performed DEA analysis of 23 Veterans Health Administration annual OR activity; 87,180 cases were performed, 24 publications generated, and 560 trainee-years of education delivered, in 168 ORs over 166,377 hours by 1,384 full-time equivalents of surgical and anesthesia providers and 523 nonproviders. RESULTS: Varying analyzed parameters produced similar efficiency rankings, with individual differences suggesting possible inefficiencies. We characterized returns to scale for efficient sites, suggesting whether patient flow might be efficiently further increased through these sites. We matched inefficient sites to similar efficient sites for comparison and suggested resource alterations to increase efficiency. CONCLUSIONS: Broader DEA application might characterize OR efficiency more informatively than conventional single-ratio rank ordering.
Authors: Nabil Elkassabany; Rebecca M Speck; David Oslin; Mary Hawn; Khan Chaichana; John Sum-Ping; Jorge Sepulveda; Mary Whitley; Yasser Sakawi Journal: Anesthesiol Res Pract Date: 2013-08-28