BACKGROUND: Gender bias has been reported in the diagnosis and treatment of patients with a variety of illnesses. In the context of our 10-station fourth year Objective Structured Clinical Evaluation, we queried whether this could influence diagnosis in a geriatric case. Case writers hypothesized that, due to this bias, the female standardized patient may be diagnosed with depression more often than the male. METHOD: A male or female geriatric standardized patient protrayed a dysphoric widow with mild cognitive impairment. Students examined the patient and documented the clinical encounter and their differential diagnosis. RESULTS: Major depression was diagnosed in 93/107 female standardized patient encounters compared with 58/78 male exams, with the female students contributing most to this difference. DISCUSSION: The potential for gender bias in medical care and in education remains a concern. We need to be mindful of this when designing clinical skills assessments.
BACKGROUND: Gender bias has been reported in the diagnosis and treatment of patients with a variety of illnesses. In the context of our 10-station fourth year Objective Structured Clinical Evaluation, we queried whether this could influence diagnosis in a geriatric case. Case writers hypothesized that, due to this bias, the female standardized patient may be diagnosed with depression more often than the male. METHOD: A male or female geriatric standardized patient protrayed a dysphoric widow with mild cognitive impairment. Students examined the patient and documented the clinical encounter and their differential diagnosis. RESULTS: Major depression was diagnosed in 93/107 female standardized patient encounters compared with 58/78 male exams, with the female students contributing most to this difference. DISCUSSION: The potential for gender bias in medical care and in education remains a concern. We need to be mindful of this when designing clinical skills assessments.
Authors: Adam L Wendling; Shivashankar Halan; Patrick Tighe; Linda Le; Tammy Euliano; Benjamin Lok Journal: Acad Med Date: 2011-03 Impact factor: 6.893
Authors: Martin Müller; Wolf E Hautz; Tanja Birrenbach; Michele Hoffmann; Stefanie C Hautz; Juliane E Kämmer; Aristomenis K Exadaktylos; Thomas C Sauter Journal: BMC Emerg Med Date: 2022-06-15