OBJECTIVES: The King's College Hospital (KCH) criteria are widely used for listing patients with acute liver failure (ALF) for liver transplantation (LT). Recent reports have suggested that the Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) score may be useful in assessing prognosis in ALF (nonparacetamol). This study compares prognostic accuracy of the two systems in patients with paracetamol (POD)-induced ALF treated in this unit. METHODS: Seventy-two patients (average age 38 years; F:M ratio 2:1) admitted from 1994 to 2005 with POD-related ALF were studied. Clinical and biochemical parameters were recorded. The effect of applying a MELD score of greater than 30 as listing criteria for LT was calculated and compared with the KCH criteria. Outcomes were defined as LT, death, or full recovery. RESULTS: Thirty-one patients (43%) recovered with medical therapy, 29 (40%) patients died, and 12 (17%) underwent LT. Sixty five percent of patients had a MELD > 30 and therefore could potentially be listed on admission; however, using KCH criteria only 24% patients were listed immediately. Sensitivity and negative predictive value of MELD was higher then KCH; however, we found KCH to have much higher specificity and positive predictive value. CONCLUSION: MELD has higher sensitivity and negative predictive value for POD-induced ALF than the KCH criteria. However, the high false-positive rate associated with MELD limits its clinical utility. The high negative predictive value of MELD score may allow it to be used in conjunction with KCH criteria to avoid unneeded LT in patients who will likely recover spontaneously.
OBJECTIVES: The King's College Hospital (KCH) criteria are widely used for listing patients with acute liver failure (ALF) for liver transplantation (LT). Recent reports have suggested that the Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) score may be useful in assessing prognosis in ALF (nonparacetamol). This study compares prognostic accuracy of the two systems in patients with paracetamol (POD)-induced ALF treated in this unit. METHODS: Seventy-two patients (average age 38 years; F:M ratio 2:1) admitted from 1994 to 2005 with POD-related ALF were studied. Clinical and biochemical parameters were recorded. The effect of applying a MELD score of greater than 30 as listing criteria for LT was calculated and compared with the KCH criteria. Outcomes were defined as LT, death, or full recovery. RESULTS: Thirty-one patients (43%) recovered with medical therapy, 29 (40%) patients died, and 12 (17%) underwent LT. Sixty five percent of patients had a MELD > 30 and therefore could potentially be listed on admission; however, using KCH criteria only 24% patients were listed immediately. Sensitivity and negative predictive value of MELD was higher then KCH; however, we found KCH to have much higher specificity and positive predictive value. CONCLUSION: MELD has higher sensitivity and negative predictive value for POD-induced ALF than the KCH criteria. However, the high false-positive rate associated with MELD limits its clinical utility. The high negative predictive value of MELD score may allow it to be used in conjunction with KCH criteria to avoid unneeded LT in patients who will likely recover spontaneously.
Authors: Donal B O'Connor; John P Burke; John Hegarty; Aiden P McCormick; Niamh Nolan; Emir Hoti; Donal Maguire; Justin Geoghegan; Oscar Traynor Journal: World J Transplant Date: 2016-06-24
Authors: David G Koch; Holly Tillman; Valerie Durkalski; William M Lee; Adrian Reuben Journal: Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol Date: 2016-04-13 Impact factor: 11.382
Authors: Brandy R Lu; Jane Gralla; Edwin Liu; Emily L Dobyns; Michael R Narkewicz; Ronald J Sokol Journal: Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol Date: 2008-10 Impact factor: 11.382
Authors: William M Lee; Linda S Hynan; Lorenzo Rossaro; Robert J Fontana; R Todd Stravitz; Anne M Larson; Timothy J Davern; Natalie G Murray; Timothy McCashland; Joan S Reisch; Patricia R Robuck Journal: Gastroenterology Date: 2009-06-12 Impact factor: 22.682