Evangelos Tziavrangos1, Stephan A Schug. 1. Department of Anaesthesia and Pain Medicine, Royal Perth Hospital, Perth, Western Australia, Australia.
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The ongoing debate on the outcome benefits of regional anaesthesia and analgesia over general anaesthesia and systemic analgesia has led to a large number of recently published papers, in particular systematic reviews and meta-analyses that justify a review of the current status of the debate. RECENT FINDINGS: Meta-analyses have shown consistently improved analgesia with epidural techniques, but the results are by far less consistent with regard to other outcomes, in particular morbidity and mortality. Specific outcomes in specific types of surgery, however, such as bowel recovery after abdominal surgery, can be improved by neuraxial blockade, which also remains the technique of choice for obstetric analgesia and anaesthesia. In certain indications, peripheral nerve blocks may have the potential to replace neuraxial blocks while maintaining the benefits of the regional technique, such as paravertebral blocks for thoracotomies. SUMMARY: Although there are a considerable number of recent publications on the topic, the complex issues around the effect of regional anaesthesia on outcome is not completely resolved, possibly because the data are often not procedure specific. In addition, however, it may be that our current literature cannot provide a definitive answer.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The ongoing debate on the outcome benefits of regional anaesthesia and analgesia over general anaesthesia and systemic analgesia has led to a large number of recently published papers, in particular systematic reviews and meta-analyses that justify a review of the current status of the debate. RECENT FINDINGS: Meta-analyses have shown consistently improved analgesia with epidural techniques, but the results are by far less consistent with regard to other outcomes, in particular morbidity and mortality. Specific outcomes in specific types of surgery, however, such as bowel recovery after abdominal surgery, can be improved by neuraxial blockade, which also remains the technique of choice for obstetric analgesia and anaesthesia. In certain indications, peripheral nerve blocks may have the potential to replace neuraxial blocks while maintaining the benefits of the regional technique, such as paravertebral blocks for thoracotomies. SUMMARY: Although there are a considerable number of recent publications on the topic, the complex issues around the effect of regional anaesthesia on outcome is not completely resolved, possibly because the data are often not procedure specific. In addition, however, it may be that our current literature cannot provide a definitive answer.
Authors: Melena D Bellin; Martin L Freeman; Andres Gelrud; Adam Slivka; Alfred Clavel; Abhinav Humar; Sarah J Schwarzenberg; Mark E Lowe; Michael R Rickels; David C Whitcomb; Jeffrey B Matthews; Stephen Amann; Dana K Andersen; Michelle A Anderson; John Baillie; Geoffrey Block; Randall Brand; Suresh Chari; Marie Cook; Gregory A Cote; Ty Dunn; Luca Frulloni; Julia B Greer; Michael A Hollingsworth; Kyung Mo Kim; Alexander Larson; Markus M Lerch; Tom Lin; Thiruvengadam Muniraj; R Paul Robertson; Seth Sclair; Shalinender Singh; Rachelle Stopczynski; Frederico G S Toledo; Charles Melbern Wilcox; John Windsor; Dhiraj Yadav Journal: Pancreatology Date: 2013-11-13 Impact factor: 3.996
Authors: Hendrik Freise; Fritz Daudel; Christina Grosserichter; Stefan Lauer; Juergen Hinkelmann; Hugo K Van Aken; Andreas W Sielenkaemper; Martin Westphal; Lars G Fischer Journal: Crit Care Date: 2009-07-13 Impact factor: 9.097
Authors: Samira M Sadowski; Axel Andres; Philippe Morel; Eduardo Schiffer; Jean-Louis Frossard; Alexandra Platon; Pierre-Alexandre Poletti; Leo Bühler Journal: World J Gastroenterol Date: 2015-11-21 Impact factor: 5.742
Authors: Müge Koşucu; Ilker Coşkun; Ahmet Eroglu; Dilek Kutanis; Ahmet Menteşe; S Caner Karahan; Emre Baki; Servet Kerimoğlu; Murat Topbas Journal: Biomed Res Int Date: 2014-02-20 Impact factor: 3.411