Kamilla L Venner1, Sarah W Feldstein. 1. Department of Psychology, Logan Hall, 1 University of New Mexico, MSC03 2220, Albuquerque, New Mexico 87131-1161, USA. kamilla@unm.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Examining the progression of a disorder cross- culturally may help distinguish elements common to addictions from those that are differentially shaped by culture. This study sought to construct a combined sequence of both problem emergence and recovery efforts with Native Americans. METHOD: In a cross-sectional sample, 44 adult Native Americans (61% men) who had resolved alcohol dependence completed face-to-face interviews at a research center. The Alcohol Related Behaviors Survey and the Change Effort Card-sorts along with measures of alcohol involvement and current quality of life were administered. RESULTS: This sample's sequence of alcohol-related events was compared to that reported for Jellinek's historical white male sample (r(s) = .46, p = .001), a recent Navajo sample (r(s) = .33, p = .024), and a recent Mission Indian sample (r(s) = .28, p = .24). This sample's sequence of change efforts was compared to that in the Navajo sample (r(s) = .33, p = .182). CONCLUSIONS: Despite the small sample size precluding generalizability, there was greater concordance between this intertribal sample and Jellinek's white male sample than between this sample and a Mission Indian sample, indicating both cross-cultural and intracultural variation. In addition, change efforts begin during the development of alcohol problems rather than waiting until the person "hits bottom," as suggested by previous research. Integrating the pathology of substance- use disorders with the process of resolving those disorders extends our understanding of the course of alcohol dependence.
OBJECTIVE: Examining the progression of a disorder cross- culturally may help distinguish elements common to addictions from those that are differentially shaped by culture. This study sought to construct a combined sequence of both problem emergence and recovery efforts with Native Americans. METHOD: In a cross-sectional sample, 44 adult Native Americans (61% men) who had resolved alcohol dependence completed face-to-face interviews at a research center. The Alcohol Related Behaviors Survey and the Change Effort Card-sorts along with measures of alcohol involvement and current quality of life were administered. RESULTS: This sample's sequence of alcohol-related events was compared to that reported for Jellinek's historical white male sample (r(s) = .46, p = .001), a recent Navajo sample (r(s) = .33, p = .024), and a recent Mission Indian sample (r(s) = .28, p = .24). This sample's sequence of change efforts was compared to that in the Navajo sample (r(s) = .33, p = .182). CONCLUSIONS: Despite the small sample size precluding generalizability, there was greater concordance between this intertribal sample and Jellinek's white male sample than between this sample and a Mission Indian sample, indicating both cross-cultural and intracultural variation. In addition, change efforts begin during the development of alcohol problems rather than waiting until the person "hits bottom," as suggested by previous research. Integrating the pathology of substance- use disorders with the process of resolving those disorders extends our understanding of the course of alcohol dependence.
Authors: Kamilla L Venner; Helen Matzger; Alyssa A Forcehimes; Rudolf H Moos; Sarah W Feldstein; Mark L Willenbring; Constance Weisner Journal: Alcohol Clin Exp Res Date: 2006-06 Impact factor: 3.455
Authors: Trina M Norden-Krichmar; Ian R Gizer; Ondrej Libiger; Kirk C Wilhelmsen; Cindy L Ehlers; Nicholas J Schork Journal: Am J Hum Biol Date: 2014-02-17 Impact factor: 1.937
Authors: Sarah Feldstein Ewing; Angela D Bryan; Genevieve F Dash; Travis I Lovejoy; Brian Borsari; Sarah J Schmiege Journal: Exp Clin Psychopharmacol Date: 2021-03-22 Impact factor: 3.492