Nicole Pouliart1, Simon Marmor, Olivier Gagey. 1. Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Academic Hospital Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels, Belgium. izvptn@az.vub.ac.be
Abstract
PURPOSE: Although an anteroinferior capsulolabral detachment (typical Bankart lesion) has been evaluated in other experimental studies, it has not yet been tested with an apprehension test in an intact shoulder model. METHODS: Adjacent combinations of 4 zones of the capsuloligamentous complex were sequentially detached from the glenoid neck in 50 cadaveric shoulders. Stability was tested before and after each resection step: inferior stability with a sulcus test and anterior stability with an anterior drawer test and with a load-and-shift test in the apprehension position. RESULTS: A metastable anteroinferior dislocation occurred in 18 specimens after section of 3 zones and in 14 only after section of 4 zones. A locked dislocation occurred after section of all 4 zones in 33 specimens and in the other 17 shoulders only after the posterior capsule was also cut. CONCLUSIONS: The humeral head cannot dislocate anteroinferiorly when there only is a Bankart lesion. In our study superior and posterior extension was necessary before the tensioning mechanism in external rotation and abduction failed enough for dislocation to occur. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Because the Bankart lesion is most likely not the only lesion present in patients with recurrent dislocation, a careful search for other lesions needs to be done when one is attempting surgical treatment. These lesions would need to be treated as well if one wants to avoid the risk of residual instability.
PURPOSE: Although an anteroinferior capsulolabral detachment (typical Bankart lesion) has been evaluated in other experimental studies, it has not yet been tested with an apprehension test in an intact shoulder model. METHODS: Adjacent combinations of 4 zones of the capsuloligamentous complex were sequentially detached from the glenoid neck in 50 cadaveric shoulders. Stability was tested before and after each resection step: inferior stability with a sulcus test and anterior stability with an anterior drawer test and with a load-and-shift test in the apprehension position. RESULTS: A metastable anteroinferior dislocation occurred in 18 specimens after section of 3 zones and in 14 only after section of 4 zones. A locked dislocation occurred after section of all 4 zones in 33 specimens and in the other 17 shoulders only after the posterior capsule was also cut. CONCLUSIONS: The humeral head cannot dislocate anteroinferiorly when there only is a Bankart lesion. In our study superior and posterior extension was necessary before the tensioning mechanism in external rotation and abduction failed enough for dislocation to occur. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Because the Bankart lesion is most likely not the only lesion present in patients with recurrent dislocation, a careful search for other lesions needs to be done when one is attempting surgical treatment. These lesions would need to be treated as well if one wants to avoid the risk of residual instability.
Authors: Hans Rahme; Ola Vikerfors; Lena Ludvigsson; Maria Elvèn; Karl Michaëlsson Journal: Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc Date: 2009-11-28 Impact factor: 4.342
Authors: Mun Chun Lai; Fu Hong Benjamin Ang; Kong Hwee Lee; Chee Cheng Paul Chang; Tjiauw Tjoen Denny Lie Journal: Asia Pac J Sports Med Arthrosc Rehabil Technol Date: 2019-09-06