BACKGROUND AND AIM OF THE STUDY: Mechanical valves are used in dialysis patients due to the presumed rapid degeneration of tissue valves. The study aim was to compare the results of mechanical and tissue valves placed in renal dialysis patients. METHODS: Information obtained from a computer-based valve replacement database, telephone interviews and patient charts was reviewed for follow up data. RESULTS: Between 1991 and 2004, 50 dialysis patients underwent left-sided valve replacement. Of these patients, 17 received 21 St. Jude Medical mechanical valves (12 aortic, nine mitral), and 33 received 39 tissue valves (19 aortic, 20 mitral). The mean follow up for the mechanical and tissue valve groups was 19.4 +/- 21.3 and 21.4 +/- 18.7 months, respectively. Mortality at four years was 65% (11/17) for the mechanical valve group, and 42% (14/33) for the tissue valve group (p = 0.15). Freedom from reoperation was not significantly different. The tissue valve group had significantly higher Kaplan-Meier freedom from thromboembolism (100% versus 75 +/- 15%, p = 0.01), hemorrhage (97 +/- 3% versus 44 +/- 17%, p = 0.002), valve-related morbidity (74 +/- 9% versus 42 +/- 16%, p = 0.043), and valve-related morbidity and mortality (69 +/- 9% versus 37 +/- 14%, p = 0.037) at three years. Linearized rates of hemorrhage (21 versus 2%/pt-yr; p = 0.005), valve-related morbidity (36 versus 12%/pt-yr; p = 0.02) and valve-related morbidity and mortality (50 versus 17%/pt-yr; p = 0.008) were all significantly higher in the mechanical valve group. CONCLUSION: Dialysis patients had poor survival; prosthetic valve degeneration was negligible. Incidences of thromboembolism, bleeding and valve-related morbidity and mortality were higher with mechanical valves. Linearized, as opposed to actuarial, analysis further accentuated the unacceptably high rates of complications and death with mechanical valves.
BACKGROUND AND AIM OF THE STUDY: Mechanical valves are used in dialysis patients due to the presumed rapid degeneration of tissue valves. The study aim was to compare the results of mechanical and tissue valves placed in renal dialysis patients. METHODS: Information obtained from a computer-based valve replacement database, telephone interviews and patient charts was reviewed for follow up data. RESULTS: Between 1991 and 2004, 50 dialysis patients underwent left-sided valve replacement. Of these patients, 17 received 21 St. Jude Medical mechanical valves (12 aortic, nine mitral), and 33 received 39 tissue valves (19 aortic, 20 mitral). The mean follow up for the mechanical and tissue valve groups was 19.4 +/- 21.3 and 21.4 +/- 18.7 months, respectively. Mortality at four years was 65% (11/17) for the mechanical valve group, and 42% (14/33) for the tissue valve group (p = 0.15). Freedom from reoperation was not significantly different. The tissue valve group had significantly higher Kaplan-Meier freedom from thromboembolism (100% versus 75 +/- 15%, p = 0.01), hemorrhage (97 +/- 3% versus 44 +/- 17%, p = 0.002), valve-related morbidity (74 +/- 9% versus 42 +/- 16%, p = 0.043), and valve-related morbidity and mortality (69 +/- 9% versus 37 +/- 14%, p = 0.037) at three years. Linearized rates of hemorrhage (21 versus 2%/pt-yr; p = 0.005), valve-related morbidity (36 versus 12%/pt-yr; p = 0.02) and valve-related morbidity and mortality (50 versus 17%/pt-yr; p = 0.008) were all significantly higher in the mechanical valve group. CONCLUSION: Dialysis patients had poor survival; prosthetic valve degeneration was negligible. Incidences of thromboembolism, bleeding and valve-related morbidity and mortality were higher with mechanical valves. Linearized, as opposed to actuarial, analysis further accentuated the unacceptably high rates of complications and death with mechanical valves.
Authors: Kevin S Kim; Emilie P Belley-Côté; Saurabh Gupta; Arjun Pandey; Ali Alsagheir; Ahmad Makhdoum; Graham McClure; Brooke Newsome; Sophie W Gao; Matthias Bossard; Tetsuya Isayama; Yasuhisa Ikuta; Michael Walsh; Amit X Garg; Gordon H Guyatt; Richard P Whitlock Journal: Can J Surg Date: 2022-07-12 Impact factor: 2.840