Literature DB >> 16633513

Looking with both eyes open: fact and value in psychiatric diagnosis?

Kenneth W M Fulford1, Matthew Broome, Giovanni Stanghellini, Tim Thornton.   

Abstract

IN THIS ARTICLE WE ARGUE THE CASE FOR A PROPOSAL: that psychiatry should recognise, embrace and take seriously the role of values, alongside facts, in diagnosis. We present a three-step argument in support of our proposal; we raise a number of key questions from the perspectives of different stakeholders in mental health; and we conclude with a note on the significance of our proposal for building a more equal relationship between patients and professionals.

Entities:  

Year:  2005        PMID: 16633513      PMCID: PMC1414736     

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  World Psychiatry        ISSN: 1723-8617            Impact factor:   49.548


  12 in total

1.  Clinicians' and clients' perspectives on the impact of assertive community treatment.

Authors:  M A Lang; L Davidson; P Bailey; M S Levine
Journal:  Psychiatr Serv       Date:  1999-10       Impact factor: 3.084

2.  What can philosophy do for psychiatry?

Authors:  Kenneth W M Fulford; Giovanni Stanghellini; Matthew Broome
Journal:  World Psychiatry       Date:  2004-10       Impact factor: 49.548

3.  Anorexia nervosa and personal identity: The accounts of patients and their parents.

Authors:  Jacinta O A Tan; Tony Hope; Anne Stewart
Journal:  Int J Law Psychiatry       Date:  2003 Sep-Oct

4.  Values in psychiatric diagnosis: executive summary of a report to the chair of the ICD-12/DSM-VI Coordination Task Force (Dateline 2010).

Authors:  K W M Fulford
Journal:  Psychopathology       Date:  2002 Mar-Jun       Impact factor: 1.944

5.  The concept of disease and its implications for psychiatry.

Authors:  R E Kendell
Journal:  Br J Psychiatry       Date:  1975-10       Impact factor: 9.319

6.  Bewitched, bothered, and deluded: a maddening pursuit of the insanity defence. [Review of: Robinson DN. Wild beasts and idle humours: the insanity defense from antiquity to the present. Harvard University Press, 1996].

Authors:  J P Eigen
Journal:  Hist Psychiatry       Date:  1997-06

7.  Philosophy and medicine: the Oxford connection.

Authors:  K W Fulford
Journal:  Br J Psychiatry       Date:  1990-07       Impact factor: 9.319

8.  Evaluating the influence of implicit models of mental disorder on processes of shared decision making within community-based multi-disciplinary teams.

Authors:  A Colombo; G Bendelow; B Fulford; S Williams
Journal:  Soc Sci Med       Date:  2003-04       Impact factor: 4.634

9.  Comprehensive diagnosis: a conceptual basis for future diagnostic systems.

Authors:  Juan E Mezzich
Journal:  Psychopathology       Date:  2002 Mar-Jun       Impact factor: 1.944

10.  Compulsory psychiatric treatment in the community. I. A controlled study of compulsory community treatment with extended leave under the Mental Health Act: special characteristics of patients treated and impact of treatment.

Authors:  T Sensky; T Hughes; S Hirsch
Journal:  Br J Psychiatry       Date:  1991-06       Impact factor: 9.319

View more
  12 in total

1.  [The role of philosophy in psychiatry].

Authors:  M Heinze; C Kupke
Journal:  Nervenarzt       Date:  2006-03       Impact factor: 1.214

2.  Fanatical about "harmful dysfunction".

Authors:  Kennethw M Fulford; Tim Thornton
Journal:  World Psychiatry       Date:  2007-10       Impact factor: 49.548

3.  Are psychiatrists an endangered species?

Authors:  Mario Maj
Journal:  World Psychiatry       Date:  2010-02       Impact factor: 49.548

4.  Medico-ethical versus biological evaluationism, and the concept of disease.

Authors:  Jon A Lindstrøm
Journal:  Med Health Care Philos       Date:  2012-05

5.  Do we have any solid evidence of clinical utility about the pathophysiology of schizophrenia?

Authors:  Stephen M Lawrie; Bayanne Olabi; Jeremy Hall; Andrew M McIntosh
Journal:  World Psychiatry       Date:  2011-02       Impact factor: 49.548

6.  Systematic inclusion of culture-related information in ICD-11.

Authors:  Oye Gureje; Roberto Lewis-Fernandez; Brian J Hall; Geoffrey M Reed
Journal:  World Psychiatry       Date:  2019-10       Impact factor: 49.548

7.  Three keys to a shared vision of diagnostic assessment: an initiative in person-centered care from the Department of Health in the UK.

Authors:  Bill Fulford; Laurie Bryant; Lu Duhig
Journal:  Int J Integr Care       Date:  2010-01-29       Impact factor: 5.120

8.  Critical evaluation of current diagnostic systems.

Authors:  Claudio E M Banzato
Journal:  Indian J Psychiatry       Date:  2008-07       Impact factor: 1.759

9.  Defining mental illnesses: can values and objectivity get along?

Authors:  Dominic Sisti; Michael Young; Arthur Caplan
Journal:  BMC Psychiatry       Date:  2013-12-24       Impact factor: 3.630

10.  Values and DSM-5: looking at the debate on attenuated psychosis syndrome.

Authors:  Arthur Maciel Nunes Gonçalves; Clarissa de Rosalmeida Dantas; Claudio E M Banzato
Journal:  BMC Med Ethics       Date:  2016-01-20       Impact factor: 2.652

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.