PURPOSE: The aim of the study is to examine the validity of manner of death (MOD) certification of unnatural adult deaths by Ontario coroners. METHODS: A census of 306 active coroners practicing in Ontario was performed, with data collection occurring in 2002. Mailed self-administered questionnaires contained 14 fictitious clinicopathologic scenarios and questions regarding demographic information of the coroner. Crude and adjusted odds ratios of correct MOD certification were calculated by using responses of two deputy chief coroners as the gold standard. RESULTS: Nearly 74% of coroners responded to the survey. Deaths from hanging, drowning, and carbon monoxide had better odds of being certified correctly; whereas deaths from heroin, over-the-counter medication, and injuries from a descent had decreased odds of being certified correctly. Scenarios including a prior suicide attempt or a note had greater odds of correct MOD certification than those with only depression. Accidental deaths were underreported when injury resulted in a "natural" lethal complication and when there was a delay between injury and death. CONCLUSIONS: In detailing which deaths are likely to be misclassified and how they may be misclassified, this study will allow future research to more accurately assess suicidal and accidental deaths.
PURPOSE: The aim of the study is to examine the validity of manner of death (MOD) certification of unnatural adult deaths by Ontario coroners. METHODS: A census of 306 active coroners practicing in Ontario was performed, with data collection occurring in 2002. Mailed self-administered questionnaires contained 14 fictitious clinicopathologic scenarios and questions regarding demographic information of the coroner. Crude and adjusted odds ratios of correct MOD certification were calculated by using responses of two deputy chief coroners as the gold standard. RESULTS: Nearly 74% of coroners responded to the survey. Deaths from hanging, drowning, and carbon monoxide had better odds of being certified correctly; whereas deaths from heroin, over-the-counter medication, and injuries from a descent had decreased odds of being certified correctly. Scenarios including a prior suicide attempt or a note had greater odds of correct MOD certification than those with only depression. Accidental deaths were underreported when injury resulted in a "natural" lethal complication and when there was a delay between injury and death. CONCLUSIONS: In detailing which deaths are likely to be misclassified and how they may be misclassified, this study will allow future research to more accurately assess suicidal and accidental deaths.
Authors: S Heide; R Lessig; V Hachmann; D Stiller; M Rönsch; D Stoevesandt; A Biolik; S Watzke; J Kellner Journal: Int J Legal Med Date: 2017-06-21 Impact factor: 2.686
Authors: Blayne Welk; Eric McArthur; Michael Ordon; Kelly K Anderson; Jade Hayward; Stephanie Dixon Journal: JAMA Intern Med Date: 2017-05-01 Impact factor: 21.873
Authors: Anne E Rhodes; Saba Khan; Michael H Boyle; Christine Wekerle; Deborah Goodman; Lil Tonmyr; Jennifer Bethell; Bruce Leslie; Ian Manion Journal: Can J Public Health Date: 2012 May-Jun
Authors: Ayal Schaffer; Mark Sinyor; Paul Kurdyak; Simone Vigod; Jitender Sareen; Catherine Reis; Diane Green; James Bolton; Anne Rhodes; Sophie Grigoriadis; John Cairney; Amy Cheung Journal: World Psychiatry Date: 2016-06 Impact factor: 49.548
Authors: Ian R H Rockett; Eric D Caine; Hilary S Connery; Gail D'Onofrio; David J Gunnell; Ted R Miller; Kurt B Nolte; Mark S Kaplan; Nestor D Kapusta; Christa L Lilly; Lewis S Nelson; Sandra L Putnam; Steven Stack; Peeter Värnik; Lynn R Webster; Haomiao Jia Journal: PLoS One Date: 2018-01-10 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Ian R H Rockett; Eric D Caine; Steven Stack; Hilary S Connery; Kurt B Nolte; Christa L Lilly; Ted R Miller; Lewis S Nelson; Sandra L Putnam; Paul S Nestadt; Haomiao Jia Journal: PLoS One Date: 2018-05-22 Impact factor: 3.240