Literature DB >> 16618333

Economic comparison of methods of wound closure: wound closure strips vs. sutures and wound adhesives.

William T Zempsky1, Cindy L Zehrer, Christopher T Lyle, Edwin C Hedbloom.   

Abstract

Our objective was to review and assess the treatment of low-tension wounds and evaluate the cost-effectiveness of wound closure methods. We used a health economic model to estimate cost/closure of adhesive wound closure strips, tissue adhesives and sutures. The model incorporated cost-driving variables: application time, costs and the likelihood and costs of dehiscence and infection. The model was populated with variable estimates derived from the literature. Cost estimates and cosmetic results were compared. Parameter values were estimated using national healthcare and labour statistics. Sensitivity analyses were used to verify the results. Our analysis suggests that adhesive wound closure strips had the lowest average cost per laceration ($7.54), the lowest cost per infected laceration ($53.40) and the lowest cost per laceration with dehiscence ($25.40). The costs for sutures were $24.11, $69.91 and $41.91, respectively; the costs for tissue adhesives were $28.77, $74.68 and $46.68, respectively. The cosmetic outcome for all three treatments was equivalent. We conclude adhesive wound closure strips were both a cost-saving and a cost-effective alternative to sutures and tissue adhesives in the closure of low-tension lacerations.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Substances:

Year:  2005        PMID: 16618333      PMCID: PMC7951558          DOI: 10.1111/j.1742-4801.2005.00130.x

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Int Wound J        ISSN: 1742-4801            Impact factor:   3.315


  29 in total

1.  The efficacy of cyanoacrylate-derived surgical adhesive for use in the repair of lacerations during competitive athletics.

Authors:  A D Perron; J A Garcia; E Parker Hays; R Schafermeyer
Journal:  Am J Emerg Med       Date:  2000-05       Impact factor: 2.469

2.  SUTURELESS SKIN CLOSURE. A CLINICAL TRIAL.

Authors:  N G ROTHNIE; G W TAYLOR
Journal:  Br Med J       Date:  1963-10-26

Review 3.  Using tissue adhesive for wound repair: a practical guide to dermabond.

Authors:  T B Bruns; J M Worthington
Journal:  Am Fam Physician       Date:  2000-03-01       Impact factor: 3.292

4.  A randomized, clinical trial comparing butylcyanoacrylate with octylcyanoacrylate in the management of selected pediatric facial lacerations.

Authors:  M H Osmond; J V Quinn; T Sutcliffe; M Jarmuske; T P Klassen
Journal:  Acad Emerg Med       Date:  1999-03       Impact factor: 3.451

5.  Comparison of skin stapling devices and standard sutures for pediatric scalp lacerations: a randomized study of cost and time benefits.

Authors:  J T Kanegaye; C W Vance; L Chan; N Schonfeld
Journal:  J Pediatr       Date:  1997-05       Impact factor: 4.406

6.  Prospective, randomized, controlled trial of tissue adhesive (2-octylcyanoacrylate) vs standard wound closure techniques for laceration repair. Stony Brook Octylcyanoacrylate Study Group.

Authors:  A J Singer; J E Hollander; S M Valentine; T W Turque; C F McCuskey; J V Quinn
Journal:  Acad Emerg Med       Date:  1998-02       Impact factor: 3.451

Review 7.  Tissue adhesives for traumatic lacerations: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials.

Authors:  Ken J Farion; Martin H Osmond; Lisa Hartling; Kelly F Russell; Terry P Klassen; Ellen Crumley; Natasha Wiebe
Journal:  Acad Emerg Med       Date:  2003-02       Impact factor: 3.451

8.  A new tissue adhesive for laceration repair in children.

Authors:  T B Bruns; B S Robinson; R J Smith; D L Kile; T P Davis; K M Sullivan; J V Quinn
Journal:  J Pediatr       Date:  1998-06       Impact factor: 4.406

9.  A randomised, controlled trial comparing a tissue adhesive (2-octylcyanoacrylate) with adhesive strips (Steristrips) for paediatric laceration repair.

Authors:  A Mattick; G Clegg; T Beattie; T Ahmad
Journal:  Emerg Med J       Date:  2002-09       Impact factor: 2.740

10.  Cosmetic outcome of scalp wound closure with staples in the pediatric emergency department: a prospective, randomized trial.

Authors:  Abu N G A Khan; Peter S Dayan; Steven Miller; Michael Rosen; David H Rubin
Journal:  Pediatr Emerg Care       Date:  2002-06       Impact factor: 1.454

View more
  3 in total

1.  Mesentery-like steri-strip: a scarless drain fixation.

Authors:  Valerio Finocchi; Maria F Bianciardi Valassina; Gianluigi Longobardi; Angelo Trivisonno; Damiano Tambasco
Journal:  Int Wound J       Date:  2014-04-21       Impact factor: 3.315

Review 2.  Tissue adhesives for traumatic lacerations in children and adults.

Authors:  K Farion; M H Osmond; L Hartling; K Russell; T Klassen; E Crumley; N Wiebe
Journal:  Cochrane Database Syst Rev       Date:  2002

3.  A Recent Advance in the Closure of Skin Wounds on Fragile Skin.

Authors:  John Ko; Jeffrey S Freed
Journal:  Case Rep Emerg Med       Date:  2021-06-26
  3 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.