Kamaldeep Bhui1, Lisa Shanahan, Geoff Harding. 1. Institute of Community Health Sciences, Barts and The London School of Medicine, Queen Mary University of London. k.s.bhui@qmul.ac.uk
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Homelessness and mental illness together confer significant morbidity and mortality because of physical health problems. Healthcare provision is undergoing significant review, and, as part of the Department of Health's policy reforms, the service user's view is central to the future restructuring of NHS services. MATERIAL: A literature review of homeless service users' perceptions of services for homeless mentally ill people was supplemented by a qualitative in-depth survey of 10 homeless people. This article reports on their views about the services they receive. Mismatch between expectations and provision, disputes with healthcare providers, dissatisfaction with the degree to which they have choice in their care, and suspicions about the intentions of health professionals demonstrate the extent to which powerlessness and social exclusion are replicated in healthcare economies. The inadequacy of hostels and their staff are also emphasised, with some recommendations for services. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: There are few data on homeless people's perceptions of services for mental health problems. Homeless people have strong views about the adequacy of services to meet their needs. They were particularly concerned about stigma, prejudice and the inadequacy and complexity of services that they have to use. This article reports their recommendations for change.
BACKGROUND: Homelessness and mental illness together confer significant morbidity and mortality because of physical health problems. Healthcare provision is undergoing significant review, and, as part of the Department of Health's policy reforms, the service user's view is central to the future restructuring of NHS services. MATERIAL: A literature review of homeless service users' perceptions of services for homeless mentally ill people was supplemented by a qualitative in-depth survey of 10 homeless people. This article reports on their views about the services they receive. Mismatch between expectations and provision, disputes with healthcare providers, dissatisfaction with the degree to which they have choice in their care, and suspicions about the intentions of health professionals demonstrate the extent to which powerlessness and social exclusion are replicated in healthcare economies. The inadequacy of hostels and their staff are also emphasised, with some recommendations for services. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: There are few data on homeless people's perceptions of services for mental health problems. Homeless people have strong views about the adequacy of services to meet their needs. They were particularly concerned about stigma, prejudice and the inadequacy and complexity of services that they have to use. This article reports their recommendations for change.
Authors: Audrey L Jones; Leslie R M Hausmann; Gretchen L Haas; Maria K Mor; John P Cashy; James H Schaefer; Adam J Gordon Journal: Psychol Serv Date: 2017-05
Authors: Ginetta Salvalaggio; Elaine Hyshka; Cara Brown; Andrew D Pinto; Gayle Halas; Lee Green; Brynn Kosteniuk; Melissa Perri; Nathaniel Le Chalifoux; Garrett Halas; Liane Steiner; Teresa Cavett; Stephanie Montesanti Journal: Can J Public Health Date: 2022-06-30
Authors: Anita Palepu; Anita M Hubley; Lara B Russell; Anne M Gadermann; Mary Chinni Journal: Health Qual Life Outcomes Date: 2012-08-15 Impact factor: 3.186
Authors: Christopher Dowrick; Linda Gask; Suzanne Edwards; Saadia Aseem; Peter Bower; Heather Burroughs; Amy Catlin; Carolyn Chew-Graham; Pam Clarke; Mark Gabbay; Simon Gowers; Derek Hibbert; Marija Kovandzic; Jonathan Lamb; Karina Lovell; Anne Rogers; Mari Lloyd-Williams; Waquas Waheed Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2009-12-10 Impact factor: 2.655
Authors: Réamonn Canavan; Margaret M Barry; Aleksandra Matanov; Henrique Barros; Edina Gabor; Tim Greacen; Petra Holcnerová; Ulrike Kluge; Pablo Nicaise; Jacek Moskalewicz; José Manuel Díaz-Olalla; Christa Strassmayr; Aart H Schene; Joaquim J F Soares; Andrea Gaddini; Stefan Priebe Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2012-07-27 Impact factor: 2.655
Authors: Linda Gask; Peter Bower; Jonathan Lamb; Heather Burroughs; Carolyn Chew-Graham; Suzanne Edwards; Derek Hibbert; Marija Kovandžić; Karina Lovell; Anne Rogers; Waquas Waheed; Christopher Dowrick Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2012-08-13 Impact factor: 2.655