Denis Ambroise1, Pascal Wild, Jean-Jacques Moulin. 1. Department of Industry-based Epidemilogy, French National Institute for Research and Safety, Vandoeuvre Les Nancy, France.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: This study is an update, over the period 1954-2004, of a previous meta-analysis completed in 1994. It was aimed at assessing lung cancer risk among welders, while addressing heterogeneity, publication bias, and confounding issues. METHODS: Combined relative risks (CRR) and their variances were calculated using fixed and random effects models. Heterogeneity was tested using the Q statistic. The publication bias was estimated using funnel plots, and Egger's regression and partially controlled by excluding studies with positive reporting bias. RESULTS: The literature provided 60 studies eligible for the meta-analysis. No heterogeneity was observed. The fixed effect CRR for all of the welders and all of the studies was 1.26 (95% CI 1.20-1.32) after partial control of publication bias. No difference was observed according to welding activities. Smoking did not appear to be a marked confounder in the relationship between lung cancer and welding, but the effect of asbestos could not be assessed. CONCLUSIONS: The meta-analysis showed a 26% excess of lung cancer for welders without any difference according to welding activities.
OBJECTIVES: This study is an update, over the period 1954-2004, of a previous meta-analysis completed in 1994. It was aimed at assessing lung cancer risk among welders, while addressing heterogeneity, publication bias, and confounding issues. METHODS: Combined relative risks (CRR) and their variances were calculated using fixed and random effects models. Heterogeneity was tested using the Q statistic. The publication bias was estimated using funnel plots, and Egger's regression and partially controlled by excluding studies with positive reporting bias. RESULTS: The literature provided 60 studies eligible for the meta-analysis. No heterogeneity was observed. The fixed effect CRR for all of the welders and all of the studies was 1.26 (95% CI 1.20-1.32) after partial control of publication bias. No difference was observed according to welding activities. Smoking did not appear to be a marked confounder in the relationship between lung cancer and welding, but the effect of asbestos could not be assessed. CONCLUSIONS: The meta-analysis showed a 26% excess of lung cancer for welders without any difference according to welding activities.
Authors: Benjamin Kendzia; Thomas Behrens; Karl-Heinz Jöckel; Jack Siemiatycki; Hans Kromhout; Roel Vermeulen; Susan Peters; Rainer Van Gelder; Ann Olsson; Irene Brüske; H-Erich Wichmann; Isabelle Stücker; Florence Guida; Adonina Tardón; Franco Merletti; Dario Mirabelli; Lorenzo Richiardi; Hermann Pohlabeln; Wolfgang Ahrens; Maria Teresa Landi; Neil Caporaso; Dario Consonni; David Zaridze; Neonila Szeszenia-Dabrowska; Jolanta Lissowska; Per Gustavsson; Michael Marcus; Eleonora Fabianova; Andrea 't Mannetje; Neil Pearce; Lap Ah Tse; Ignatius Tak-Sun Yu; Peter Rudnai; Vladimir Bencko; Vladimir Janout; Dana Mates; Lenka Foretova; Francesco Forastiere; John McLaughlin; Paul Demers; Bas Bueno-de-Mesquita; Paolo Boffetta; Joachim Schüz; Kurt Straif; Beate Pesch; Thomas Brüning Journal: Am J Epidemiol Date: 2013-09-19 Impact factor: 4.897
Authors: Elizabeth M Ward; Paul A Schulte; Kurt Straif; Nancy B Hopf; Jane C Caldwell; Tania Carreón; David M DeMarini; Bruce A Fowler; Bernard D Goldstein; Kari Hemminki; Cynthia J Hines; Kirsti Husgafvel Pursiainen; Eileen Kuempel; Joellen Lewtas; Ruth M Lunn; Elsebeth Lynge; Damien M McElvenny; Hartwig Muhle; Tamie Nakajima; Larry W Robertson; Nathaniel Rothman; Avima M Ruder; Mary K Schubauer-Berigan; Jack Siemiatycki; Debra Silverman; Martyn T Smith; Tom Sorahan; Kyle Steenland; Richard G Stevens; Paolo Vineis; Shelia Hoar Zahm; Lauren Zeise; Vincent J Cogliano Journal: Environ Health Perspect Date: 2010-06-18 Impact factor: 9.031
Authors: Darren R Brenner; Rayjean J Hung; Ming-Sound Tsao; Frances A Shepherd; Michael R Johnston; Steven Narod; Warren Rubenstein; John R McLaughlin Journal: BMC Cancer Date: 2010-06-14 Impact factor: 4.430
Authors: Eric Vallières; Javier Pintos; Jérôme Lavoué; Marie-Élise Parent; Bernard Rachet; Jack Siemiatycki Journal: Cancer Med Date: 2012-06-07 Impact factor: 4.452
Authors: Patti C Zeidler-Erdely; Terence G Meighan; Aaron Erdely; Lori A Battelli; Michael L Kashon; Michael Keane; James M Antonini Journal: Part Fibre Toxicol Date: 2013-09-05 Impact factor: 9.400
Authors: A d'Errico; S Pasian; A Baratti; R Zanelli; S Alfonzo; L Gilardi; F Beatrice; A Bena; G Costa Journal: Occup Environ Med Date: 2009-01-19 Impact factor: 4.402