PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to assess the significance of Stage I diagnoses of lung cancer in the baseline cycle of screening for this disease, with special reference to the potential for overdiagnosis. METHODS: We reviewed all 69 cases of Stage I lung cancer diagnosis resulting from our baseline CT screening. Among these 69 cases of lung cancer, 24 presented as solid, 30 as part-solid, and 15 as nonsolid nodules. The extent to which these represented genuine malignancy was assessed by a panel of experts on lung pathology, and the "aggressiveness" of these cases was addressed by the criterion of the tumor's volume doubling time being less than 400 days. RESULTS: The expert panel confirmed all 69 cases as representing genuine malignancy. Among the 69 cases without evidence of metastases, the proportion that satisfied the aggressiveness criterion was 60/69=87%. The corresponding proportions by presentation as solid, part-solid, and nonsolid nodule were 23/24 (96%), 27/30 (90%), and 10/15 (67%), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: In baseline CT screening for lung cancer, overdiagnosis of the disease is uncommon, with cases presenting as a nonsolid nodule a possible exception to this.
PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to assess the significance of Stage I diagnoses of lung cancer in the baseline cycle of screening for this disease, with special reference to the potential for overdiagnosis. METHODS: We reviewed all 69 cases of Stage I lung cancer diagnosis resulting from our baseline CT screening. Among these 69 cases of lung cancer, 24 presented as solid, 30 as part-solid, and 15 as nonsolid nodules. The extent to which these represented genuine malignancy was assessed by a panel of experts on lung pathology, and the "aggressiveness" of these cases was addressed by the criterion of the tumor's volume doubling time being less than 400 days. RESULTS: The expert panel confirmed all 69 cases as representing genuine malignancy. Among the 69 cases without evidence of metastases, the proportion that satisfied the aggressiveness criterion was 60/69=87%. The corresponding proportions by presentation as solid, part-solid, and nonsolid nodule were 23/24 (96%), 27/30 (90%), and 10/15 (67%), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: In baseline CT screening for lung cancer, overdiagnosis of the disease is uncommon, with cases presenting as a nonsolid nodule a possible exception to this.
Authors: M Regier; S Kandel; M G Kaul; B Hoffmann; H Ittrich; P M Bansmann; J Kemper; C Nolte-Ernsting; M Heller; G Adam; J Biederer Journal: Eur Radiol Date: 2006-09-30 Impact factor: 5.315
Authors: David F Yankelevitz; Rowena Yip; James P Smith; Mingzhu Liang; Ying Liu; Dong Ming Xu; Mary M Salvatore; Andrea S Wolf; Raja M Flores; Claudia I Henschke Journal: Radiology Date: 2015-06-23 Impact factor: 11.105
Authors: Chul Hwan Park; Dong Jin Im; Sang Min Lee; Ji Won Lee; Sung Ho Hwang; Semin Chong; Min Jae Cha; Kye Ho Lee; Woocheol Kwon; Hwan Seok Yong; Jae Wook Lee; Gong Yong Jin; Sang Hyun Paik; Kyunghwa Han; Jin Hur Journal: Contemp Clin Trials Commun Date: 2017-12-07
Authors: Claudia I Henschke; Rowena Yip; Dorith Shaham; Javier J Zulueta; Samuel M Aguayo; Anthony P Reeves; Artit Jirapatnakul; Ricardo Avila; Drew Moghanaki; David F Yankelevitz Journal: J Thorac Imaging Date: 2021-01 Impact factor: 5.528