BACKGROUND: The accuracy and precision of ultrasonography (US) in assessing the severity of autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is unknown. METHODS: US and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) were performed at baseline and 1 year on 230 subjects with ADPKD. Ellipsoid volume was calculated from US length, width, and depth, and sequential transverse images were used to measure total and cystic volume directly. These were compared with MRI measurements of kidney volume and cystic volume. RESULTS: Variability between different sonographers ranged from 18% to 42%. Correlations between US and MRI volume were 0.88 and 0.89. The SD of the discrepancy from MRI ranged from 21% to 33% and was unrelated to kidney size or body mass. Kidney length was the most reproducible measurement, and its correlation with MRI volume was 0.84. All patients with an US volume less than 700 cm3 had an MRI volume less than 1,000 cm3, and all patients with an US volume greater than 1,700 cm3 had an MRI volume greater than 1,000 cm3. Increases in volume after 1 year were 12% +/- 36% for the ellipsoid method, 6% +/- 29% for the direct method, and 4.2% +/- 7.2% for MRI. Correlation between US and MRI measurement of fractional cyst volume was 0.80. CONCLUSION: Sonographic measurement of kidney volume in patients with ADPKD is inaccurate and lacks the precision necessary to measure short-term disease progression. However, sonography can provide an estimate of kidney volume that reflects severity and prognosis in individual patients.
BACKGROUND: The accuracy and precision of ultrasonography (US) in assessing the severity of autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is unknown. METHODS: US and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) were performed at baseline and 1 year on 230 subjects with ADPKD. Ellipsoid volume was calculated from US length, width, and depth, and sequential transverse images were used to measure total and cystic volume directly. These were compared with MRI measurements of kidney volume and cystic volume. RESULTS: Variability between different sonographers ranged from 18% to 42%. Correlations between US and MRI volume were 0.88 and 0.89. The SD of the discrepancy from MRI ranged from 21% to 33% and was unrelated to kidney size or body mass. Kidney length was the most reproducible measurement, and its correlation with MRI volume was 0.84. All patients with an US volume less than 700 cm3 had an MRI volume less than 1,000 cm3, and all patients with an US volume greater than 1,700 cm3 had an MRI volume greater than 1,000 cm3. Increases in volume after 1 year were 12% +/- 36% for the ellipsoid method, 6% +/- 29% for the direct method, and 4.2% +/- 7.2% for MRI. Correlation between US and MRI measurement of fractional cyst volume was 0.80. CONCLUSION: Sonographic measurement of kidney volume in patients with ADPKD is inaccurate and lacks the precision necessary to measure short-term disease progression. However, sonography can provide an estimate of kidney volume that reflects severity and prognosis in individual patients.
Authors: Luc Breysem; Stéphanie De Rechter; Frederik De Keyzer; Maria Helena Smet; Bert Bammens; Maria Van Dyck; Maarten Hofmans; Raymond Oyen; Elena Levtchenko; Djalila Mekahli Journal: Pediatr Nephrol Date: 2018-01-06 Impact factor: 3.714
Authors: Arlene B Chapman; Olivier Devuyst; Kai-Uwe Eckardt; Ron T Gansevoort; Tess Harris; Shigeo Horie; Bertram L Kasiske; Dwight Odland; York Pei; Ronald D Perrone; Yves Pirson; Robert W Schrier; Roser Torra; Vicente E Torres; Terry Watnick; David C Wheeler Journal: Kidney Int Date: 2015-03-18 Impact factor: 10.612