BACKGROUND: Intensivists manage a diverse team of health care professionals. For decades, business literature has recognized the value of leadership and management skills, yet this is relatively unexplored in critical care. OBJECTIVE: Investigate the status of intensivists' preparation for the clinical leadership and management roles that they will assume after medical training. DESIGN: Authoritative business leadership literature was reviewed to identify attributes of successful leadership and management relevant to critical care. A survey was designed to assess the process by which intensivists learn these attributes and to assess their perceived level of preparedness (20 items). Each survey item received a preparedness score structured as a Likert scale (1=not prepared, 5=very prepared), representing the averaged response to each item. In addition, an inadequate preparedness percentage was created representing the percentage of respondents answering "not at all prepared" and "hardly prepared" on the Likert-scaled items. SETTING: Pediatric Critical Care Medicine Board Review Course, Washington, DC, 2004. SUBJECTS: Physician course participants (n=259). INTERVENTION: Survey administration. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The response rate was 61% (n = 159). The majority of respondents (69%) had completed fellowship training (median, 1 yr posttraining). Modeling the behavior of other physicians was the dominant technique for leadership and management skill acquisition (86%). The respondents were taught these skills by a variety of sources (attendings, 92%; other fellows, 42%; nurses, 37%; teachers, 20%; residents, 14%). Most (82%) thought that leadership and management training was important or very important, yet only 47% had received any formal training (40% fellowship, 36% residency, 21% medical school, 16% masters, 30% other). Overall, respondents felt only "somewhat prepared" for the 20 leadership and management items surveyed (mean+/- sd of preparedness score, 2.8+/- 0.2). Respondents were least prepared to manage conflict within a team, manage conflict with other groups, and manage stress effectively (preparedness scores of 2.5, 2.4, and 2.6 and inadequate preparedness percentages of 19.5%, 15.7%, and 18.9%, respectively). Respondents were most prepared to "set high standards" (preparedness score=3.3). Of the respondents feeling at least somewhat prepared, only 33% credited medical training as preparing them. CONCLUSIONS: Although leadership and management training was perceived as important to this sample of pediatric generally young intensivists, most feel inadequately prepared for critical aspects of these responsibilities, most notably, stress and conflict management. These findings provide an opportunity for specific curriculum development in leadership and management for those believing these skills should be further refined.
BACKGROUND: Intensivists manage a diverse team of health care professionals. For decades, business literature has recognized the value of leadership and management skills, yet this is relatively unexplored in critical care. OBJECTIVE: Investigate the status of intensivists' preparation for the clinical leadership and management roles that they will assume after medical training. DESIGN: Authoritative business leadership literature was reviewed to identify attributes of successful leadership and management relevant to critical care. A survey was designed to assess the process by which intensivists learn these attributes and to assess their perceived level of preparedness (20 items). Each survey item received a preparedness score structured as a Likert scale (1=not prepared, 5=very prepared), representing the averaged response to each item. In addition, an inadequate preparedness percentage was created representing the percentage of respondents answering "not at all prepared" and "hardly prepared" on the Likert-scaled items. SETTING: Pediatric Critical Care Medicine Board Review Course, Washington, DC, 2004. SUBJECTS: Physician course participants (n=259). INTERVENTION: Survey administration. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The response rate was 61% (n = 159). The majority of respondents (69%) had completed fellowship training (median, 1 yr posttraining). Modeling the behavior of other physicians was the dominant technique for leadership and management skill acquisition (86%). The respondents were taught these skills by a variety of sources (attendings, 92%; other fellows, 42%; nurses, 37%; teachers, 20%; residents, 14%). Most (82%) thought that leadership and management training was important or very important, yet only 47% had received any formal training (40% fellowship, 36% residency, 21% medical school, 16% masters, 30% other). Overall, respondents felt only "somewhat prepared" for the 20 leadership and management items surveyed (mean+/- sd of preparedness score, 2.8+/- 0.2). Respondents were least prepared to manage conflict within a team, manage conflict with other groups, and manage stress effectively (preparedness scores of 2.5, 2.4, and 2.6 and inadequate preparedness percentages of 19.5%, 15.7%, and 18.9%, respectively). Respondents were most prepared to "set high standards" (preparedness score=3.3). Of the respondents feeling at least somewhat prepared, only 33% credited medical training as preparing them. CONCLUSIONS: Although leadership and management training was perceived as important to this sample of pediatric generally young intensivists, most feel inadequately prepared for critical aspects of these responsibilities, most notably, stress and conflict management. These findings provide an opportunity for specific curriculum development in leadership and management for those believing these skills should be further refined.
Authors: Ernest Frugé; Joan M Lakoski; Naomi Luban; Jeffrey M Lipton; David G Poplack; Anne Hagey; Judy Felgenhauer; Joanne Hilden; Judith Margolin; Sarah R Vaiselbuh; Kathleen M Sakamoto Journal: Pediatr Blood Cancer Date: 2011-01-31 Impact factor: 3.167
Authors: Ashley Siems; Russell Banks; Richard Holubkov; Kathleen L Meert; Christian Bauerfeld; David Beyda; Robert A Berg; Yonca Bulut; Randall S Burd; Joseph Carcillo; J Michael Dean; Eleanor Gradidge; Mark W Hall; Patrick S McQuillen; Peter M Mourani; Christopher J L Newth; Daniel A Notterman; Margaret A Priestley; Anil Sapru; David L Wessel; Andrew R Yates; Athena F Zuppa; Murray M Pollack Journal: Hosp Pediatr Date: 2020-01
Authors: Daniel M Blumenthal; Ken Bernard; Traci N Fraser; Jordan Bohnen; Jessica Zeidman; Valerie E Stone Journal: BMC Med Educ Date: 2014-11-30 Impact factor: 2.463