BACKGROUND: Cost-effectiveness of radiofrequency ablation (RFA) was assessed in treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). PATIENTS AND METHODS: During 5 years, 153 patients with HCC of 3cm or less received RFA, and 60 underwent surgery. Judgment after RFA therapy was classified into three grades: residual tumor (grade 1), necrotic area with a less safety margin of 5mm (grade 2), and necrosis with a safety margin of 5mm in all directions (grade 3). RESULTS: Local recurrence rates after RFA and surgery were 7.9% and 0% at the third year. The rates in patients with grades 2 and 3 after RFA were 18.7% and 1.2% at the third year, respectively (P=0.0005). Among 91 patients with grades 1 and 2 necrosis after initial therapy, 52 received additional ablation. Although local recurrence rate was 24.9% in 39 patients without additional therapy, the rates after therapy repetition were 10.9% in 21 patients with eventual grade 2 necrosis, and 0% in 31 patients with grade 3 (P=0.038). Median costs of single RFA, repeated RFA, and surgery were yen849,900, yen1,086,000, and yen1,745,100, respectively. Additional ablation reduced local recurrence by 20.7% at the cost of yen236,100. CONCLUSION: Cost-effectiveness of RFA in the treatment of small HCC was superior to that of surgery.
BACKGROUND: Cost-effectiveness of radiofrequency ablation (RFA) was assessed in treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). PATIENTS AND METHODS: During 5 years, 153 patients with HCC of 3cm or less received RFA, and 60 underwent surgery. Judgment after RFA therapy was classified into three grades: residual tumor (grade 1), necrotic area with a less safety margin of 5mm (grade 2), and necrosis with a safety margin of 5mm in all directions (grade 3). RESULTS: Local recurrence rates after RFA and surgery were 7.9% and 0% at the third year. The rates in patients with grades 2 and 3 after RFA were 18.7% and 1.2% at the third year, respectively (P=0.0005). Among 91 patients with grades 1 and 2 necrosis after initial therapy, 52 received additional ablation. Although local recurrence rate was 24.9% in 39 patients without additional therapy, the rates after therapy repetition were 10.9% in 21 patients with eventual grade 2 necrosis, and 0% in 31 patients with grade 3 (P=0.038). Median costs of single RFA, repeated RFA, and surgery were yen849,900, yen1,086,000, and yen1,745,100, respectively. Additional ablation reduced local recurrence by 20.7% at the cost of yen236,100. CONCLUSION: Cost-effectiveness of RFA in the treatment of small HCC was superior to that of surgery.
Authors: Samer Tohme; David A Geller; Jon S Cardinal; Hui-Wei Chen; Vignesh Packiam; Srinevas Reddy; Jennifer Steel; James W Marsh; Allan Tsung Journal: HPB (Oxford) Date: 2012-08-12 Impact factor: 3.647