AIM: During the past decades the treatment of severe paralytic scoliosis has developed towards surgical treatment. However there is controversial discussion about the need of pre-operative Halo-traction. The aim of this study was to built two groups of patients -- one group with and another one without pre-operative Halo-traction -- and to compare the results after surgical correction of scoliotic deformity with data from literature. METHOD: Between 2000-2003 twenty-five patients with severe neuromuscular spine deformity were treated surgically. Eight patients had preoperative Halo-traction, seventeen patients underwent directly operative correction and instrumentation. The evaluation included the pre- and postoperative X-rays as well those after Halo-traction before surgery. RESULTS: In the group without Halo-traction the scoliotic angle according to Cobb was reduced from 77 degrees to 33 degrees on average (mean correction of 44 degrees [57 %]). In the group with Halo-traction scoliosis was reduced from 85 degrees to 33 degrees on average (mean correction of 52 degrees [61 %]). CONCLUSION: The preoperative Halo-traction in patients with severe neuromuscular scoliosis indeed leads to radiologically higher correction, but this is not significant (p = 0.19) and only in single cases clinically relevant. In our point of view except from specific indications Halo-traction should not be applied in general as a standard procedure.
AIM: During the past decades the treatment of severe paralytic scoliosis has developed towards surgical treatment. However there is controversial discussion about the need of pre-operative Halo-traction. The aim of this study was to built two groups of patients -- one group with and another one without pre-operative Halo-traction -- and to compare the results after surgical correction of scoliotic deformity with data from literature. METHOD: Between 2000-2003 twenty-five patients with severe neuromuscular spine deformity were treated surgically. Eight patients had preoperative Halo-traction, seventeen patients underwent directly operative correction and instrumentation. The evaluation included the pre- and postoperative X-rays as well those after Halo-traction before surgery. RESULTS: In the group without Halo-traction the scoliotic angle according to Cobb was reduced from 77 degrees to 33 degrees on average (mean correction of 44 degrees [57 %]). In the group with Halo-traction scoliosis was reduced from 85 degrees to 33 degrees on average (mean correction of 52 degrees [61 %]). CONCLUSION: The preoperative Halo-traction in patients with severe neuromuscular scoliosis indeed leads to radiologically higher correction, but this is not significant (p = 0.19) and only in single cases clinically relevant. In our point of view except from specific indications Halo-traction should not be applied in general as a standard procedure.
Authors: Hongda Bao; Peng Yan; Mike Bao; Yong Qiu; Zezhang Zhu; Zhen Liu; Jack C Y Cheng; Bobby K W Ng; Feng Zhu Journal: Eur Spine J Date: 2016-05-27 Impact factor: 3.134