BACKGROUND: Therapeutic enemas are often used to treat active colitis but their retention may be limited because of urgency to defecate. Some preparations may be better retained and tolerated than others because of their physical properties. AIM: To compare patient preference and retention of four therapeutic enemas, including a nicotine enema, in patients with ulcerative colitis (UC). METHODS:Twenty four patients with active UC received the four trial enemas-corticosteroid, 5-amino salicylate (5-ASA), and nicotine liquid enemas and a corticosteroid foam, in a randomised order, taking one enema on each of four successive nights. Patients scored them 1 to 4 for ease of administration and retention, degree of abdominal bloating, and for their overall preference. RESULTS: Fifteen patients rated nicotine their overall favourite or second favourite, compared with 14 for corticosteroid foam and 11 for 5-ASA and corticosteroid liquids, but this was not significant (p = 0.302). Overall, there was no significant difference in overnight retention. However, the nicotine enema tended to be less well retained in patients with milder urgency but a higher proportion retained it overnight with more severe urgency (p = 0.031 compared with 5-ASA enema). CONCLUSION: There was no significant difference in patient preference or overall duration of retention for the four enemas.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: Therapeutic enemas are often used to treat active colitis but their retention may be limited because of urgency to defecate. Some preparations may be better retained and tolerated than others because of their physical properties. AIM: To compare patient preference and retention of four therapeutic enemas, including a nicotine enema, in patients with ulcerative colitis (UC). METHODS: Twenty four patients with active UC received the four trial enemas-corticosteroid, 5-amino salicylate (5-ASA), and nicotine liquid enemas and a corticosteroid foam, in a randomised order, taking one enema on each of four successive nights. Patients scored them 1 to 4 for ease of administration and retention, degree of abdominal bloating, and for their overall preference. RESULTS: Fifteen patients rated nicotine their overall favourite or second favourite, compared with 14 for corticosteroid foam and 11 for 5-ASA and corticosteroid liquids, but this was not significant (p = 0.302). Overall, there was no significant difference in overnight retention. However, the nicotine enema tended to be less well retained in patients with milder urgency but a higher proportion retained it overnight with more severe urgency (p = 0.031 compared with 5-ASA enema). CONCLUSION: There was no significant difference in patient preference or overall duration of retention for the four enemas.
Authors: M Campieri; G A Lanfranchi; G Bazzocchi; C Brignola; F Sarti; G Franzin; A Battocchia; G Labo; P R Dal Monte Journal: Lancet Date: 1981-08-08 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: J T Green; C Richardson; R W Marshall; J Rhodes; H C McKirdy; G A Thomas; G T Williams Journal: Aliment Pharmacol Ther Date: 2000-11 Impact factor: 8.171
Authors: F I Lee; D P Jewell; V Mani; M R Keighley; R D Kingston; C O Record; R H Grace; S Daniels; J Patterson; K Smith Journal: Gut Date: 1996-02 Impact factor: 23.059
Authors: L R Sutherland; F Martin; S Greer; M Robinson; N Greenberger; F Saibil; T Martin; J Sparr; E Prokipchuk; L Borgen Journal: Gastroenterology Date: 1987-06 Impact factor: 22.682