Literature DB >> 16132072

The right to remain in ignorance about genetic information--can such a right be defended in the name of autonomy?

Phillipa Malpas1.   

Abstract

Within the field of medicine, it has become widely accepted that respecting the autonomy of individuals justifies their right to know. More recently, commentators have asked whether such respect also justifies an individual's right not to know; that is, their right to remain in ignorance. In this paper, I examine what the concept of autonomy entails and whether one is justified in exercising a right not to know genetic information about oneself in the name of autonomy. An important distinction is drawn between autonomous choices generally and autonomous choices about how we shall conduct our lives. Against this theoretical discussion, I consider two hypothetical cases. I conclude by claiming that ignorance cannot be justified in the name of autonomy, and furthermore that where genetic information is pertinent to one's future autonomy, one cannot exercise a right not to know.

Mesh:

Year:  2005        PMID: 16132072

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  N Z Med J        ISSN: 0028-8446


  8 in total

1.  A framework for youth-friendly genetic counseling.

Authors:  Mary-Anne Young; Kate Thompson; Jeremy Lewin; Lucy Holland
Journal:  J Community Genet       Date:  2019-11-05

2.  The Ethics of General Population Preventive Genomic Sequencing: Rights and Social Justice.

Authors:  Clair Morrissey; Rebecca L Walker
Journal:  J Med Philos       Date:  2018-01-12

3.  Free Choice and Patient Best Interests.

Authors:  Emma C Bullock
Journal:  Health Care Anal       Date:  2016-12

4.  The right not to know: the case of psychiatric disorders.

Authors:  Lisa Bortolotti; Heather Widdows
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2011-06-09       Impact factor: 2.903

5.  The relative importance of undesirable truths.

Authors:  Lisa Bortolotti
Journal:  Med Health Care Philos       Date:  2013-11

6.  Incidental findings of uncertain significance: To know or not to know--that is not the question.

Authors:  Bjørn Hofmann
Journal:  BMC Med Ethics       Date:  2016-02-13       Impact factor: 2.652

7.  What can we Learn from Patients' Ethical Thinking about the right 'not to know' in Genomics? Lessons from Cancer Genetic Testing for Genetic Counselling.

Authors:  Lorraine Cowley
Journal:  Bioethics       Date:  2016-08-15       Impact factor: 1.898

Review 8.  Principles of Genetic Counseling in the Era of Next-Generation Sequencing.

Authors:  Mina Yang; Jong Won Kim
Journal:  Ann Lab Med       Date:  2018-07       Impact factor: 3.464

  8 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.