Anelise Santo1, Andréa M Laizner, Linda Shohet. 1. Nursing Research, Montreal General Hospital, McGill University Health Centre, 1650 Cedar Av., Rm. D6-156, Montreal, Que., Canada H3G 1A4. nresasst@muhc.mcgill.ca
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the efficacy of audiotapes as a health information exchange intervention, specifically looking for use with the "hard-to-reach" population. METHODS: Examined electronic databases and journals for articles that evaluated potential of audiotapes as an educational tool within diverse populations. The systematic review included randomized controlled trials, surveys and exploratory articles. Primary outcome variables analyzed were knowledge and recall, behavioral change, anxiety, self-care, and satisfaction. RESULTS: Audiotapes were used to record consultations and health-related information in specific health situations. No studies were found that targeted the needs of the "hard-to-reach" population. With the exception of positive patient satisfaction, the benefits of audio taped messages remain unclear. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: If even the average person is compromised in the context of information exchange, populations with communication barriers are at even greater risk. Research needs to be conducted, aimed at determining whether audiotapes enhance communication between the "hard-to-reach" population and health professionals.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the efficacy of audiotapes as a health information exchange intervention, specifically looking for use with the "hard-to-reach" population. METHODS: Examined electronic databases and journals for articles that evaluated potential of audiotapes as an educational tool within diverse populations. The systematic review included randomized controlled trials, surveys and exploratory articles. Primary outcome variables analyzed were knowledge and recall, behavioral change, anxiety, self-care, and satisfaction. RESULTS: Audiotapes were used to record consultations and health-related information in specific health situations. No studies were found that targeted the needs of the "hard-to-reach" population. With the exception of positive patient satisfaction, the benefits of audio taped messages remain unclear. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: If even the average person is compromised in the context of information exchange, populations with communication barriers are at even greater risk. Research needs to be conducted, aimed at determining whether audiotapes enhance communication between the "hard-to-reach" population and health professionals.
Authors: Miyong T Kim; Hee-Jung Song; Hae-Ra Han; Youngshin Song; Soohyun Nam; Tam Hieu Nguyen; Ho-Chang Benjamin Lee; Kim B Kim Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2011-10-24
Authors: Stuart W Grande; Mary Ganger Castaldo; Elizabeth Carpenter-Song; Ida Griesemer; Glyn Elwyn Journal: Health Expect Date: 2016-09-07 Impact factor: 3.377