AIMS: Nodal expression of the carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), cytokeratin 20 (CK20), and guanylyl cyclase C (GCC) genes was measured in tandem in patients with colorectal cancer (CRC) to assess whether there would be sufficient agreement between these markers in their ability to detect micrometastasis to qualify one of them as a universal marker, and whether frozen and paraffin wax embedded tissues would yield similar results. METHODS: One hundred and seventy five frozen lymph nodes (FT) and 158 formalin fixed, paraffin wax embedded lymph nodes (PET) from 28 CRC cases were analysed using gene specific quantitative real time polymerase chain reaction, carried out on the LightCycler system with SYBR Green chemistry. RESULTS: There was significant disparity in positive detection of the three biomarkers in FT versus PET, with notable agreement achieved only for CEA (66.6%) in FT versus PET in Dukes' B disease, and between CK20 and GCC (44.6%) in FT, also in Dukes' B disease. One patient with full concordance in all three tumour markers with both tissue types suffered a relapse and died within two years of follow up. CONCLUSIONS: There was considerable discordance in the positive detection of the three tumour markers in both tissue types (FT versus PET). This brings into question whether using a single tumour marker to detect micrometastasis in one tissue type (FT or PET) is adequately representative, and challenges the concept of universal markers for molecular CRC metastatic detection. Multiple tumour markers would predict more accurately the metastatic potential of Dukes' B CRCs.
AIMS: Nodal expression of the carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), cytokeratin 20 (CK20), and guanylyl cyclase C (GCC) genes was measured in tandem in patients with colorectal cancer (CRC) to assess whether there would be sufficient agreement between these markers in their ability to detect micrometastasis to qualify one of them as a universal marker, and whether frozen and paraffin wax embedded tissues would yield similar results. METHODS: One hundred and seventy five frozen lymph nodes (FT) and 158 formalin fixed, paraffin wax embedded lymph nodes (PET) from 28 CRC cases were analysed using gene specific quantitative real time polymerase chain reaction, carried out on the LightCycler system with SYBR Green chemistry. RESULTS: There was significant disparity in positive detection of the three biomarkers in FT versus PET, with notable agreement achieved only for CEA (66.6%) in FT versus PET in Dukes' B disease, and between CK20 and GCC (44.6%) in FT, also in Dukes' B disease. One patient with full concordance in all three tumour markers with both tissue types suffered a relapse and died within two years of follow up. CONCLUSIONS: There was considerable discordance in the positive detection of the three tumour markers in both tissue types (FT versus PET). This brings into question whether using a single tumour marker to detect micrometastasis in one tissue type (FT or PET) is adequately representative, and challenges the concept of universal markers for molecular CRC metastatic detection. Multiple tumour markers would predict more accurately the metastatic potential of Dukes' B CRCs.
Authors: M Mitas; K Mikhitarian; C Walters; P L Baron; B M Elliott; T E Brothers; J G Robison; J S Metcalf; Y Y Palesch; Z Zhang; W E Gillanders; D J Cole Journal: Int J Cancer Date: 2001-07-15 Impact factor: 7.396
Authors: E Evron; W C Dooley; C B Umbricht; D Rosenthal; N Sacchi; E Gabrielson; A B Soito; D T Hung; B Ljung; N E Davidson; S Sukumar Journal: Lancet Date: 2001-04-28 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Siva Raja; Talal El-Hefnawy; Lori A Kelly; Melissa L Chestney; James D Luketich; Tony E Godfrey Journal: Clin Chem Date: 2002-08 Impact factor: 8.327
Authors: B Cagir; A Gelmann; J Park; T Fava; A Tankelevitch; E W Bittner; E J Weaver; J P Palazzo; D Weinberg; R D Fry; S A Waldman Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 1999-12-07 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: R Moll; R Zimbelmann; M D Goldschmidt; M Keith; J Laufer; M Kasper; P J Koch; W W Franke Journal: Differentiation Date: 1993-06 Impact factor: 3.880