Ori Rogowski1, Yaffa Vered, Itzhak Shapira, Meirav Hirsh, Vera Zakut, Shlomo Berliner. 1. Department of Medicine D and Institute for Special Medical Examinations (MALRAM), Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center, Tel Aviv, affiliated to Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, 6 Weizman Street, Tel Aviv 64239, Israel.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The determination of low grade inflammation in apparently healthy individuals (microinflammation) has prognostic significance in terms of future vascular events and accelerated atherothrombotic disease. METHODS: We compared the Bayer wide range (wr)-C-reactive protein (CRP) immunoturbidometric assay on the ADVIA 1650 system to the Dade Behring high sensitivity (hs)-CRP on the BNII Nephelometer in 1446 apparently healthy individuals having a relatively low (<10 mg/l) concentration. The correlation between the 2 assays was also analyzed in relation to other commonly used microinflammatory biomarkers. RESULTS: A significant (p<0.0005) correlation was noted between the hs-CRP and the wr-CRP for the entire cohort (r=0.99) as well as for both women (r=0.99 n=483) and men (r=0.99 n=963). The mean difference between the measures (hs-CRP minus wr-CRP) was -0.039 (SD 0.317). The Deming regression results for the entire cohort showed a slope of 1.112+/-0.004 and an intercept of -0.263+/-0.01. CONCLUSIONS: The Bayer wr-CRP assay performed presents a reasonable alternative to the Behring Dade hs-CRP assay. The advantages of the wr-CRP assay are its online and real time availability as well as lower costs.
BACKGROUND: The determination of low grade inflammation in apparently healthy individuals (microinflammation) has prognostic significance in terms of future vascular events and accelerated atherothrombotic disease. METHODS: We compared the Bayer wide range (wr)-C-reactive protein (CRP) immunoturbidometric assay on the ADVIA 1650 system to the Dade Behring high sensitivity (hs)-CRP on the BNII Nephelometer in 1446 apparently healthy individuals having a relatively low (<10 mg/l) concentration. The correlation between the 2 assays was also analyzed in relation to other commonly used microinflammatory biomarkers. RESULTS: A significant (p<0.0005) correlation was noted between the hs-CRP and the wr-CRP for the entire cohort (r=0.99) as well as for both women (r=0.99 n=483) and men (r=0.99 n=963). The mean difference between the measures (hs-CRP minus wr-CRP) was -0.039 (SD 0.317). The Deming regression results for the entire cohort showed a slope of 1.112+/-0.004 and an intercept of -0.263+/-0.01. CONCLUSIONS: The Bayer wr-CRP assay performed presents a reasonable alternative to the Behring Dade hs-CRP assay. The advantages of the wr-CRP assay are its online and real time availability as well as lower costs.
Authors: Jeremy M Silverman; Michal Schnaider Beeri; James Schmeidler; Clive Rosendorff; Gary Angelo; Rizalina S Mavris; Hillel T Grossman; Gregory A Elder; Jose Carrion-Baralt; Rebecca West Journal: Age Ageing Date: 2009-01-15 Impact factor: 10.668