Is the ABO incompatibility a risk factor in bone marrow transplantation?

ABO histo-bloodgroups are strong transplantation antigens. In bone marrow transplantation, foreign ABO red cell antigens are not ignored by the immune system of the host, neither by the immunocompetent cells of the graft. Although ABO incompatibility is not considered a contraindication in bone marrow transplantation (BMT), its clinical consequences are still a matter of investigation. An overview of reports published by different groups is given and discussed. They present conflicting data regarding the role of the ABO match between patient and donor in the haematopoietic stem cell (HSC) transplantation. We report on the clinical outcome of bone marrow transplantation in 223 patients who received grafts from MHC identical siblings. Included are 139 ABO identical, 32 ABO minor mismatched, 34 major mismatched and 13 bi-directionally mismatched pairs. The statistical evaluation of standard parameters used to monitor the post-transplant period gave a proof that in neither group of patients with an ABO incompatible donor the recovery and success rate of transplantation, including the relapse incidence, risk of graft vs. host disease (GVHD) or overall survival, were significantly inferior. However, in all three cohorts of ABO mismatched patients, a delayed recovery of neutrophils was recorded as compared to the group receiving an ABO compatible graft. These finding leads us to the conclusion that the ABO compatibility is not a disadvantage in BMT, whereas the delayed recovery of neutrophils in patients having received an ABO mismatched graft is probably reflecting a transient humoral process leading to immune tolerance and graft accommodation.