S Kamath1, D Bramley. 1. Monklands Hospital, Airdrie, Lanarkshire. hskamath5@hotmail.com
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The role of the 'clicky hip' symptom as a prognostic predictor of developmental dysplasia of hip (DDH) is controversial. We aim to study the role of isolated hip clicks as a prognostic predictor of DDH. MATERIAL AND METHODS: 235 babies with persisting or referred with clicky hip beyond six weeks of age were prospectively followed up to note the incidence of DDH. Of these 176 babies were referred for a hip click without additional risk factors. RESULTS: 7 out of 176 cases (4-IIa, 2-IIb, 1-IIc) had initial abnormal ultrasound examination based on Graf classification. However, all babies with isolated hip clicks eventually had normal hips on clinical and radiographic examination. DISCUSSION: While screening of babies with clicky hips does help in diagnosing the odd case of DDH this is not. consistently reproducible. Modifying the targeted ultrasound screening by including clicky hip as a risk factor will not reduce the incidence of missed cases. Isolated clicks in the hip joint beyond six weeks age are rarely a predictor of DDH. However when in doubt such cases should be referred to be reviewed by an orthopaedic surgeon or a radiologist experienced in hip ultrasound.
BACKGROUND: The role of the 'clicky hip' symptom as a prognostic predictor of developmental dysplasia of hip (DDH) is controversial. We aim to study the role of isolated hip clicks as a prognostic predictor of DDH. MATERIAL AND METHODS: 235 babies with persisting or referred with clicky hip beyond six weeks of age were prospectively followed up to note the incidence of DDH. Of these 176 babies were referred for a hip click without additional risk factors. RESULTS: 7 out of 176 cases (4-IIa, 2-IIb, 1-IIc) had initial abnormal ultrasound examination based on Graf classification. However, all babies with isolated hip clicks eventually had normal hips on clinical and radiographic examination. DISCUSSION: While screening of babies with clicky hips does help in diagnosing the odd case of DDH this is not. consistently reproducible. Modifying the targeted ultrasound screening by including clicky hip as a risk factor will not reduce the incidence of missed cases. Isolated clicks in the hip joint beyond six weeks age are rarely a predictor of DDH. However when in doubt such cases should be referred to be reviewed by an orthopaedic surgeon or a radiologist experienced in hip ultrasound.