BACKGROUND: Influenza may cause severe disease in immunosuppressed patients. Different vaccines have been proved to be efficacious to prevent influenza in tranplant recipients. Since the last five years the addition of adjuvants to improve the immune response to vaccine preparations has been proposed and evaluated. In this study, two antigenically identical vaccines, but different for the presence of adjuvants were randomised among a cohort of heart transplant recipients to evaluate their safety and immunogenicity. METHODS: 58 patients, receiving an heart transplant more than 6 months before, were randomised to receive one shoot vaccination with Fluad (containing the MF59 adjuvant) or Agrippal (no adjuvant added) or to enter the control, not-vaccinated, group. The immune response to influenza was evaluated separately for type A and type B viruses and for the IgG and the IgM antibodies. Patients were clinically evaluated at least monthly up to 6 months. RESULTS:Influenza symptoms were reported by 33% of patients receiving Fluad, 29% of the Agrippal and 63% of the control group. 4 episodes of acute myocardial rejection >/=3A were identified without difference between the three groups. CONCLUSIONS: The superior efficacy of vaccines containing adjuvants was not found and the data clearly confirmed that vaccination against influenza is safe and effective in heart transplant recipients. The use of vaccine containing adjuvant substances do not ameliorate the clinical performance of the immunisation suggesting that less expensive influenza vaccine preparation without adjuvant substances could be equally useful to protect heart transplant recipients.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: Influenza may cause severe disease in immunosuppressed patients. Different vaccines have been proved to be efficacious to prevent influenza in tranplant recipients. Since the last five years the addition of adjuvants to improve the immune response to vaccine preparations has been proposed and evaluated. In this study, two antigenically identical vaccines, but different for the presence of adjuvants were randomised among a cohort of heart transplant recipients to evaluate their safety and immunogenicity. METHODS: 58 patients, receiving an heart transplant more than 6 months before, were randomised to receive one shoot vaccination with Fluad (containing the MF59 adjuvant) or Agrippal (no adjuvant added) or to enter the control, not-vaccinated, group. The immune response to influenza was evaluated separately for type A and type B viruses and for the IgG and the IgM antibodies. Patients were clinically evaluated at least monthly up to 6 months. RESULTS: Influenza symptoms were reported by 33% of patients receiving Fluad, 29% of the Agrippal and 63% of the control group. 4 episodes of acute myocardial rejection >/=3A were identified without difference between the three groups. CONCLUSIONS: The superior efficacy of vaccines containing adjuvants was not found and the data clearly confirmed that vaccination against influenza is safe and effective in heart transplant recipients. The use of vaccine containing adjuvant substances do not ameliorate the clinical performance of the immunisation suggesting that less expensive influenza vaccine preparation without adjuvant substances could be equally useful to protect heart transplant recipients.
Authors: W James Chon; Pradeep V Kadambi; Robert C Harland; J Richard Thistlethwaite; Bradford L West; Suneel Udani; Rajiv Poduval; Michelle A Josephson Journal: Clin J Am Soc Nephrol Date: 2010-07-01 Impact factor: 8.237
Authors: Lara Danziger-Isakov; Leonid Cherkassky; Hanni Siegel; Mary McManamon; Kristen Kramer; Marie Budev; Deirdre Sawinski; Joshua J Augustine; Donald E Hricik; Robert Fairchild; Peter S Heeger; Emilio D Poggio Journal: Transplantation Date: 2010-04-15 Impact factor: 4.939
Authors: Rebecca Pellett Madan; Maria Tan; Ana Fernandez-Sesma; Thomas M Moran; Sukru Emre; Andrew Campbell; Betsy C Herold Journal: Clin Infect Dis Date: 2008-03-01 Impact factor: 9.079
Authors: Charles R Beck; Bruce C McKenzie; Ahmed B Hashim; Rebecca C Harris; Arina Zanuzdana; Gabriel Agboado; Elizabeth Orton; Laura Béchard-Evans; Gemma Morgan; Charlotte Stevenson; Rachel Weston; Mitsuru Mukaigawara; Joanne Enstone; Glenda Augustine; Mobasher Butt; Sophie Kim; Richard Puleston; Girija Dabke; Robert Howard; Julie O'Boyle; Mary O'Brien; Lauren Ahyow; Helene Denness; Siobhan Farmer; Jose Figureroa; Paul Fisher; Felix Greaves; Munib Haroon; Sophie Haroon; Caroline Hird; Rachel Isba; David A Ishola; Marko Kerac; Vivienne Parish; Jonathan Roberts; Julia Rosser; Sarah Theaker; Dean Wallace; Neil Wigglesworth; Liz Lingard; Yana Vinogradova; Hiroshi Horiuchi; Javier Peñalver; Jonathan S Nguyen-Van-Tam Journal: PLoS One Date: 2011-12-22 Impact factor: 3.240