OBJECTIVE: To determine if women's dress shoes with heels of just 1.5 in (3.8 cm) in height increases knee joint torques, which are thought to be relevant to the development and/or progression of knee osteoarthritis (OA) in both the medial and patellofemoral compartments. DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial. SETTING: A 3-dimensional motion analysis gait laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-nine healthy young women (age, 26.7+/-5.0 y) and 20 healthy elderly adult women (age, 75.3+/-6.5 y). INTERVENTIONS: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Peak external varus knee torque in early and late stance and prolongation of flexor knee torque in early stance. Three-dimensional data on lower-extremity torques and motion were collected during walking while (1) wearing shoes with 1.5-in high heels and (2) wearing control shoes without any additional heel. Data were plotted and qualitatively compared; major peak values and timing were statistically compared between the 2 conditions using paired t tests. RESULTS:Peak knee varus torque during late stance was statistically significantly greater with the heeled shoes than with the controls, with increases of 14% in the young women and 9% in the elderly women. With the heeled shoes, the early stance phase knee flexor torque was significantly prolonged, by 19% in the young women and by 14% in elderly women. Also, the peak flexor torque was 7% higher with the heeled shoe in the elderly women. CONCLUSIONS: Even shoes with moderately high heels (1.5 in) significantly increase knee torques thought to be relevant in the development and/or progression of knee OA. Women, particularly those who already have knee OA, should be advised against wearing these types of shoes.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To determine if women's dress shoes with heels of just 1.5 in (3.8 cm) in height increases knee joint torques, which are thought to be relevant to the development and/or progression of knee osteoarthritis (OA) in both the medial and patellofemoral compartments. DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial. SETTING: A 3-dimensional motion analysis gait laboratory. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-nine healthy young women (age, 26.7+/-5.0 y) and 20 healthy elderly adult women (age, 75.3+/-6.5 y). INTERVENTIONS: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Peak external varus knee torque in early and late stance and prolongation of flexor knee torque in early stance. Three-dimensional data on lower-extremity torques and motion were collected during walking while (1) wearing shoes with 1.5-in high heels and (2) wearing control shoes without any additional heel. Data were plotted and qualitatively compared; major peak values and timing were statistically compared between the 2 conditions using paired t tests. RESULTS: Peak knee varus torque during late stance was statistically significantly greater with the heeled shoes than with the controls, with increases of 14% in the young women and 9% in the elderly women. With the heeled shoes, the early stance phase knee flexor torque was significantly prolonged, by 19% in the young women and by 14% in elderly women. Also, the peak flexor torque was 7% higher with the heeled shoe in the elderly women. CONCLUSIONS: Even shoes with moderately high heels (1.5 in) significantly increase knee torques thought to be relevant in the development and/or progression of knee OA. Women, particularly those who already have knee OA, should be advised against wearing these types of shoes.
Authors: Najia Shakoor; Mondira Sengupta; Kharma C Foucher; Markus A Wimmer; Louis F Fogg; Joel A Block Journal: Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken) Date: 2010-07 Impact factor: 4.794
Authors: Matthew R Titchenal; Jessica L Asay; Julien Favre; Thomas P Andriacchi; Constance R Chu Journal: J Orthop Res Date: 2014-12-22 Impact factor: 3.494
Authors: Gaurav Telhan; Jason R Franz; Jay Dicharry; Robert P Wilder; Patrick O Riley; D Casey Kerrigan Journal: J Athl Train Date: 2010 Jan-Feb Impact factor: 2.860