Rafik El-Sabrout1, Kerri Buch. 1. Department of Transplantation, New York Medical College, Valhalla, NY, USA. sabroutr@wcmc.com
Abstract
AIM: Outcomes of single renal transplants from donors <5 yr old have traditionally been inferior to those from older donors. We retrospectively studied our experience with patients who received renal transplants, either individually or en bloc, from young donors (<5 yr of age) to determine the utility of these organs. We also compared the outcomes of these transplant patients maintained on either cyclosporine- (CyA) or tacrolimus-based (TRL) immunosuppression regimens. PATIENTS: Ninety-eight patients received transplants at our center from donors <5 yr of age between August 1993 and August 2003. They were followed-up from 12 months to 11 yr. Patients were divided into four groups based on whether they received single or en bloc transplants, and whether CyA or TRL was the base immunosuppressive agent. Patients in group I (n = 13) received single pediatric kidneys and were treated with CyA regimens; group II patients (n = 26) also received single pediatric kidneys, but were treated with TRL regimens; group III patients (n = 31) were transplanted en bloc and were treated with CyA; and group IV patients (n = 28) received en bloc transplants and were treated with TRL. RESULTS: One-year patient and death-censored graft survival was not significantly different between recipients of en bloc vs. single grafts (i.e. 88 and 85% vs. 90 and 87%, respectively), or between the four treatment groups (group I: 85 and 85%, group II: 92 and 88%, group III: 87 and 84%, and group IV: 89 and 86%, respectively). The overall 1-yr rejection rate was 30% (29 of 98), which was significantly higher in the CyA-treated patients 19 of 44; i.e. 43%, than in TRL-treated patients 10 of 54, i.e. 19%, p = 0.03). In the en bloc recipients, seven grafts (12%) were lost as a result of vascular thrombosis. Notably, none of the single kidneys were lost because of vascular thrombosis. At the end of follow-up the creatinine levels of both groups were comparable. CONCLUSIONS: Pediatric donor kidneys transplanted individually provide for equal patient and graft survival when compared with en bloc transplants. TRL can be used reduce the detrimental effect of acute rejection on graft growth and function when compared with CyA. Single use of such kidneys can safely and efficaciously be transplanted into adult recipients, greatly expanding the donor pool.
AIM: Outcomes of single renal transplants from donors <5 yr old have traditionally been inferior to those from older donors. We retrospectively studied our experience with patients who received renal transplants, either individually or en bloc, from young donors (<5 yr of age) to determine the utility of these organs. We also compared the outcomes of these transplant patients maintained on either cyclosporine- (CyA) or tacrolimus-based (TRL) immunosuppression regimens. PATIENTS: Ninety-eight patients received transplants at our center from donors <5 yr of age between August 1993 and August 2003. They were followed-up from 12 months to 11 yr. Patients were divided into four groups based on whether they received single or en bloc transplants, and whether CyA or TRL was the base immunosuppressive agent. Patients in group I (n = 13) received single pediatric kidneys and were treated with CyA regimens; group II patients (n = 26) also received single pediatric kidneys, but were treated with TRL regimens; group III patients (n = 31) were transplanted en bloc and were treated with CyA; and group IV patients (n = 28) received en bloc transplants and were treated with TRL. RESULTS: One-year patient and death-censored graft survival was not significantly different between recipients of en bloc vs. single grafts (i.e. 88 and 85% vs. 90 and 87%, respectively), or between the four treatment groups (group I: 85 and 85%, group II: 92 and 88%, group III: 87 and 84%, and group IV: 89 and 86%, respectively). The overall 1-yr rejection rate was 30% (29 of 98), which was significantly higher in the CyA-treated patients 19 of 44; i.e. 43%, than in TRL-treated patients 10 of 54, i.e. 19%, p = 0.03). In the en bloc recipients, seven grafts (12%) were lost as a result of vascular thrombosis. Notably, none of the single kidneys were lost because of vascular thrombosis. At the end of follow-up the creatinine levels of both groups were comparable. CONCLUSIONS: Pediatric donor kidneys transplanted individually provide for equal patient and graft survival when compared with en bloc transplants. TRL can be used reduce the detrimental effect of acute rejection on graft growth and function when compared with CyA. Single use of such kidneys can safely and efficaciously be transplanted into adult recipients, greatly expanding the donor pool.
Authors: Yousef Al-Shraideh; Umar Farooq; Hany El-Hennawy; Alan C Farney; Amudha Palanisamy; Jeffrey Rogers; Giuseppe Orlando; Muhammad Khan; Amber Reeves-Daniel; William Doares; Scott Kaczmorski; Michael D Gautreaux; Samy S Iskandar; Gloria Hairston; Elizabeth Brim; Margaret Mangus; Robert J Stratta Journal: World J Transplant Date: 2016-03-24