M Rutter1. 1. Institute of Psychiatry, Kings College, London, UK. j.wickham@iop.kcl.ac.uk
Abstract
AIM: Several reviews have noted a huge increase in the rate of diagnosed autism spectrum disorders. The main aims of this paper are: 1) to use published empirical findings to consider whether the rise reflects a true increase in incidence, as distinct from the consequences of better ascertainment and a broadening of the diagnostic concept; and 2) to consider how epidemiological data may be used to test hypotheses about possible causal influences, using MMR and thimerosal as examples. METHODS: Search of the literature for studies with a large epidemiological base population, systematic standardized screening, a focus on an age group for which diagnostic assessments are reliable and valid, and diagnosis by trained professionals using high-quality research assessments. Also, search of a broader literature to consider the evidence from all epidemiological studies with respect to the hypothesized causal effect of MMR and thimerosal on autism spectrum disorders. RESULTS: The true incidence of autism spectrum disorders is likely to be within the range of 30-60 cases per 10 000, a huge increase over the original estimate 40 years ago of 4 per 10000. The increase is largely a consequence of improved ascertainment and a considerable broadening of the diagnostic concept. However, a true risk due to some, as yet to be identified, environmental risk factor cannot be ruled out. There is no support for the hypothesis for a role of either MMR or thimerosal in causation, but the evidence on the latter is more limited. CONCLUSION: Progress in testing environmental risk hypotheses will require the integration of epidemiological and biological studies.
AIM: Several reviews have noted a huge increase in the rate of diagnosed autism spectrum disorders. The main aims of this paper are: 1) to use published empirical findings to consider whether the rise reflects a true increase in incidence, as distinct from the consequences of better ascertainment and a broadening of the diagnostic concept; and 2) to consider how epidemiological data may be used to test hypotheses about possible causal influences, using MMR and thimerosal as examples. METHODS: Search of the literature for studies with a large epidemiological base population, systematic standardized screening, a focus on an age group for which diagnostic assessments are reliable and valid, and diagnosis by trained professionals using high-quality research assessments. Also, search of a broader literature to consider the evidence from all epidemiological studies with respect to the hypothesized causal effect of MMR and thimerosal on autism spectrum disorders. RESULTS: The true incidence of autism spectrum disorders is likely to be within the range of 30-60 cases per 10 000, a huge increase over the original estimate 40 years ago of 4 per 10000. The increase is largely a consequence of improved ascertainment and a considerable broadening of the diagnostic concept. However, a true risk due to some, as yet to be identified, environmental risk factor cannot be ruled out. There is no support for the hypothesis for a role of either MMR or thimerosal in causation, but the evidence on the latter is more limited. CONCLUSION: Progress in testing environmental risk hypotheses will require the integration of epidemiological and biological studies.
Authors: Rachel Nonkin Avchen; Lisa D Wiggins; Owen Devine; Kim Van Naarden Braun; Catherine Rice; Nancy C Hobson; Diana Schendel; Marshalyn Yeargin-Allsopp Journal: J Autism Dev Disord Date: 2011-02
Authors: Laura A Schieve; Catherine Rice; Owen Devine; Matthew J Maenner; Li-Ching Lee; Robert Fitzgerald; Martha S Wingate; Diana Schendel; Sydney Pettygrove; Kim van Naarden Braun; Maureen Durkin Journal: Ann Epidemiol Date: 2011-10-13 Impact factor: 3.797
Authors: Moran Hausman-Kedem; Barry E Kosofsky; Gail Ross; Kaleb Yohay; Emily Forrest; Margaret H Dennin; Reena Patel; Kristen Bennett; James P Holahan; Mary J Ward Journal: J Psychopathol Behav Assess Date: 2018-01-20
Authors: Yang Cao; Aimin Chen; Robert L Jones; Jerilynn Radcliffe; Kathleen L Caldwell; Kim N Dietrich; Walter J Rogan Journal: Neurotoxicology Date: 2009-12-05 Impact factor: 4.294