Eric Marsh1, Susan E Melamed, Todd Barron, Robert R Clancy. 1. The Division of Neurology and the Pediatric Regional Epilepsy Program of The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia 19104, USA. marshe@email.chop.edu
Abstract
PURPOSE: The constellation of early-onset, unprovoked, alternating electroclinical seizures and neurodevelopmental devastation was first described by Coppola et al. We report six new patients and the prospect of a more optimistic developmental outcome. METHODS: Retrospective chart reviews were performed on six infants evaluated at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (five patients) and at Hershey Medical Center (one patient) who had electroclinically alternating seizures before age 6 months of age. Electroclinical characteristics and long-term follow-up were recorded. RESULTS: All had unprovoked, early-onset (range, 1 day to 3 months; mean, 25 days) intractable electroclinical seizures that alternated between the two hemispheres. Each patient underwent comprehensive brain imaging and neurometabolic workups, which were unrevealing. In all patients, subsequently intractable partial seizures developed and often a progressive decline of head circumference percentile occurred with age. Three demonstrated severe developmental delay and hypotonia. All survived, and 7-year follow-up on one patient was quite favorable. CONCLUSIONS: Our patients satisfied the seven major diagnostic criteria first described by Coppola et al. The prognosis of this rare neonatal-onset epilepsy syndrome from the original description and subsequent case reports was very poor, with 28% mortality, and the majority of survivors were profoundly retarded and nonambulatory. Our patient data validate the diagnostic criteria of this syndrome and further quantify a previously described observation of progressive decline of head circumference percentiles with age. Our data also suggest that the prognosis of this syndrome, although poor, is not as uniformly grim as the cases reported previously in the literature.
PURPOSE: The constellation of early-onset, unprovoked, alternating electroclinical seizures and neurodevelopmental devastation was first described by Coppola et al. We report six new patients and the prospect of a more optimistic developmental outcome. METHODS: Retrospective chart reviews were performed on six infants evaluated at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (five patients) and at Hershey Medical Center (one patient) who had electroclinically alternating seizures before age 6 months of age. Electroclinical characteristics and long-term follow-up were recorded. RESULTS: All had unprovoked, early-onset (range, 1 day to 3 months; mean, 25 days) intractable electroclinical seizures that alternated between the two hemispheres. Each patient underwent comprehensive brain imaging and neurometabolic workups, which were unrevealing. In all patients, subsequently intractable partial seizures developed and often a progressive decline of head circumference percentile occurred with age. Three demonstrated severe developmental delay and hypotonia. All survived, and 7-year follow-up on one patient was quite favorable. CONCLUSIONS: Our patients satisfied the seven major diagnostic criteria first described by Coppola et al. The prognosis of this rare neonatal-onset epilepsy syndrome from the original description and subsequent case reports was very poor, with 28% mortality, and the majority of survivors were profoundly retarded and nonambulatory. Our patient data validate the diagnostic criteria of this syndrome and further quantify a previously described observation of progressive decline of head circumference percentiles with age. Our data also suggest that the prognosis of this syndrome, although poor, is not as uniformly grim as the cases reported previously in the literature.
Authors: D Carranza Rojo; L Hamiwka; J M McMahon; L M Dibbens; T Arsov; A Suls; T Stödberg; K Kelley; E Wirrell; B Appleton; M Mackay; J L Freeman; S C Yendle; S F Berkovic; T Bienvenu; P De Jonghe; D R Thorburn; J C Mulley; H C Mefford; I E Scheffer Journal: Neurology Date: 2011-07-13 Impact factor: 9.910
Authors: Yanling Wang; Catherine A Dye; Vikaas Sohal; Jason E Long; Rosanne C Estrada; Tomas Roztocil; Thomas Lufkin; Karl Deisseroth; Scott C Baraban; John L R Rubenstein Journal: J Neurosci Date: 2010-04-14 Impact factor: 6.167
Authors: Emily R Freilich; Julie M Jones; William D Gaillard; Joan A Conry; Tammy N Tsuchida; Christine Reyes; Sulayman Dib-Hajj; Stephen G Waxman; Miriam H Meisler; Phillip L Pearl Journal: Arch Neurol Date: 2011-05
Authors: Amy McTague; Richard Appleton; Shivaram Avula; J Helen Cross; Mary D King; Thomas S Jacques; Sanjay Bhate; Anthony Cronin; Andrew Curran; Archana Desurkar; Michael A Farrell; Elaine Hughes; Rosalind Jefferson; Karine Lascelles; John Livingston; Esther Meyer; Ailsa McLellan; Annapurna Poduri; Ingrid E Scheffer; Stefan Spinty; Manju A Kurian; Rachel Kneen Journal: Brain Date: 2013-04-18 Impact factor: 13.501
Authors: Giulia Barcia; Matthew R Fleming; Aline Deligniere; Valeswara-Rao Gazula; Maile R Brown; Maeva Langouet; Haijun Chen; Jack Kronengold; Avinash Abhyankar; Roberta Cilio; Patrick Nitschke; Anna Kaminska; Nathalie Boddaert; Jean-Laurent Casanova; Isabelle Desguerre; Arnold Munnich; Olivier Dulac; Leonard K Kaczmarek; Laurence Colleaux; Rima Nabbout Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2012-10-21 Impact factor: 38.330