AIM: Decreases in depth and irregularity are typical changes of the acetabulum in patients with Perthes disease and develop secondary to the femoral head involvement. Optimal timing of therapy plays an important role to prevent these secondary changes. The present study investigates the influence of the amount of femoral head involvement and the patients' age on the acetabulum and the outcome. METHODS: 66 patients with 76 affected hip joints were included in the study. 20 hips had a conservative therapy, 22 an operative therapy (IVO). 34 hip joints underwent a conservative therapy at first, followed by an operative intervention. The radiomorphometric analyses at the time of diagnosis, pre- and postoperatively and at follow-up were performed with epiphyseal ratio, acetabular ratio and acetabulum-head ratio. At the time of diagnosis the patients were classified with the Catterall classification, at follow-up with Mose classification. RESULTS: Independent from therapy there was a correlation of the parameters with Catterall classification over the whole course, i.e., the higher the Catterall group the worse the parameter at the time of diagnosis as well as at follow-up. Operatively treated patients with Catterall IV tended towards a worse result of the epiphyseal ratio whereas they achieved better results in the other parameters compared to conservatively treated patients. Catteral I and II patients achieved good results. CONCLUSION: Operative treatment of the higher Catterall groups seems to be more effective than conservative therapy. Secondary changes of the acetabulum develop in proportion to the amount of femoral head involvement.
AIM: Decreases in depth and irregularity are typical changes of the acetabulum in patients with Perthes disease and develop secondary to the femoral head involvement. Optimal timing of therapy plays an important role to prevent these secondary changes. The present study investigates the influence of the amount of femoral head involvement and the patients' age on the acetabulum and the outcome. METHODS: 66 patients with 76 affected hip joints were included in the study. 20 hips had a conservative therapy, 22 an operative therapy (IVO). 34 hip joints underwent a conservative therapy at first, followed by an operative intervention. The radiomorphometric analyses at the time of diagnosis, pre- and postoperatively and at follow-up were performed with epiphyseal ratio, acetabular ratio and acetabulum-head ratio. At the time of diagnosis the patients were classified with the Catterall classification, at follow-up with Mose classification. RESULTS: Independent from therapy there was a correlation of the parameters with Catterall classification over the whole course, i.e., the higher the Catterall group the worse the parameter at the time of diagnosis as well as at follow-up. Operatively treated patients with Catterall IV tended towards a worse result of the epiphyseal ratio whereas they achieved better results in the other parameters compared to conservatively treated patients. Catteral I and II patients achieved good results. CONCLUSION: Operative treatment of the higher Catterall groups seems to be more effective than conservative therapy. Secondary changes of the acetabulum develop in proportion to the amount of femoral head involvement.
Authors: Klaus A Siebenrock; Helen Anwander; Corinne A Zurmühle; Moritz Tannast; Theddy Slongo; Simon D Steppacher Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2015-04 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Andrej Stančák; Jakub Kautzner; Petr Chládek; Ondřej Adamec; Vojtěch Havlas; Tomáš Trč Journal: Int Orthop Date: 2022-09-29 Impact factor: 3.479