Literature DB >> 1567147

The challenge of evaluating surgical procedures.

G M Stirrat1, S C Farrow, J Farndon, N Dwyer.   

Abstract

All new interventions and procedures must be properly assessed in comparison to the currently accepted method(s). It is unethical not to do so. The optimum method is by Randomised Controlled Trial (RCT). This is ideally suited to the testing of drugs because the trial can usually be double blind and placebo controlled. RCTs are less commonly used for the evaluation of new surgical techniques. There are valid and invalid reasons for this and these are discussed.

Mesh:

Year:  1992        PMID: 1567147      PMCID: PMC2497523     

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Ann R Coll Surg Engl        ISSN: 0035-8843            Impact factor:   1.891


  18 in total

1.  Randomization of the first patient.

Authors:  T C Chalmers
Journal:  Med Clin North Am       Date:  1975-07       Impact factor: 5.456

2.  The randomized clinical trial in orthopaedics: obligation or option?

Authors:  Sally Rudicel; John Esdaile
Journal:  J Bone Joint Surg Am       Date:  1985-10       Impact factor: 5.284

3.  Design considerations for AIDS trials.

Authors:  D P Byar; D A Schoenfeld; S B Green; D A Amato; R Davis; V De Gruttola; D M Finkelstein; C Gatsonis; R D Gelber; S Lagakos
Journal:  N Engl J Med       Date:  1990-11-08       Impact factor: 91.245

4.  The personal doctor 1975.

Authors:  J S McCormick
Journal:  J R Coll Gen Pract       Date:  1976-10

5.  Laparoscopic cholecystectomy.

Authors:  C Wastell
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  1991-02-09

6.  Treatment of functional menorrhagia by radiofrequency-induced thermal endometrial ablation.

Authors:  J H Phipps; B V Lewis; T Roberts; M V Prior; J W Hand; M Elder; S B Field
Journal:  Lancet       Date:  1990-02-17       Impact factor: 79.321

7.  Mortality and reoperation after open and transurethral resection of the prostate for benign prostatic hyperplasia.

Authors:  N P Roos; J E Wennberg; D J Malenka; E S Fisher; K McPherson; T F Andersen; M M Cohen; E Ramsey
Journal:  N Engl J Med       Date:  1989-04-27       Impact factor: 91.245

8.  Is surgery worthwhile?

Authors:  E W Salzman
Journal:  Arch Surg       Date:  1985-07

9.  The practical and ethical defects of surgical randomised prospective trials.

Authors:  A Byer
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  1983-06       Impact factor: 2.903

10.  Prediction of outcome after curative resection for large bowel cancer.

Authors:  L P Fielding; R K Phillips; J S Fry; R Hittinger
Journal:  Lancet       Date:  1986-10-18       Impact factor: 79.321

View more
  13 in total

1.  The Study Centre of the German Surgical Society--rationale and current status.

Authors:  Hanns-Peter Knaebel; Markus K Diener; Moritz N Wente; Hartwig Bauer; Markus W Büchler; Matthias Rothmund; Christoph M Seiler
Journal:  Langenbecks Arch Surg       Date:  2005-02-22       Impact factor: 3.445

Review 2.  Innovation in surgery: a historical perspective.

Authors:  Daniel J Riskin; Michael T Longaker; Michael Gertner; Thomas M Krummel
Journal:  Ann Surg       Date:  2006-11       Impact factor: 12.969

Review 3.  Use of cyanoacrylate adhesives in general surgery.

Authors:  David García Cerdá; Antonio Martín Ballester; Alicia Aliena-Valero; Anna Carabén-Redaño; José M Lloris
Journal:  Surg Today       Date:  2014-10-25       Impact factor: 2.549

4.  Evaluating new surgical procedures.

Authors:  I Russell
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  1995-11-11

Review 5.  Ethics and evidence based surgery.

Authors:  G M Stirrat
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2004-04       Impact factor: 2.903

6.  Brain tumor protocols in North America.

Authors:  M Bernstein; J Rutka
Journal:  J Neurooncol       Date:  1993-09       Impact factor: 4.130

7.  Randomised trial support for orthopaedic surgical procedures.

Authors:  Hyeung C Lim; Sam Adie; Justine M Naylor; Ian A Harris
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2014-06-13       Impact factor: 3.240

8.  The challenges faced in the design, conduct and analysis of surgical randomised controlled trials.

Authors:  Jonathan A Cook
Journal:  Trials       Date:  2009-02-06       Impact factor: 2.279

9.  Recruitment to publicly funded trials--are surgical trials really different?

Authors:  Jonathan A Cook; Craig R Ramsay; John Norrie
Journal:  Contemp Clin Trials       Date:  2008-03-07       Impact factor: 2.226

10.  Time to be BRAVE: is educating surgeons the key to unlocking the potential of randomised clinical trials in surgery? A qualitative study.

Authors:  Shelley Potter; Nicola Mills; Simon J Cawthorn; Jenny Donovan; Jane M Blazeby
Journal:  Trials       Date:  2014-03-14       Impact factor: 2.279

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.