BACKGROUND: The prognosis for patients with scirrhous gastric cancer (SGC) is extremely poor. However, the management protocol for this type of cancer has not been well discussed. In this study, we retrospectively evaluated the management of SGC and we introduced a new treatment protocol for SGC. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 1991 and 2001, 58 patients with SGC were treated. Thirty-nine, who underwent gastrectomy, were divided into 3 sub-groups according to peritoneal metastasis (P) and peritoneal washing cytology (CY) status [P(-)/CY(-), P(-)/CY(+), and P(+)/CY(+)]. The survival rates of these 3 sub-groups were compared with patients who did not have a gastrectomy (n=19), retrospectively. From 2002, we started a new treatment protocol for SGC. Laparoscopic diagnosis of P or CY and intraperitoneal chemotherapy (IPC) were performed before performing laparotomy on 10 patients with SGC. RESULTS: The 5-year survival rate of the 19 patients in P(-)/CY(-) was 11.6%. The survival rates of patients with P(-)/CY(+) or patients with P(+)/CY(+) were no different from patients who did not have gastrectomy (pleural effusion or ascites negative). In 10 patients who were treated with the new protocol, 7 with P(-)/CY(-) underwent gastrectomy after IPC and 3 with P(+)/CY(+) underwent repeated IPC. CONCLUSION: Gastrectomy may not have prognostic benefit for patients with SGC with CY(+). Thus, we recommend laparoscopic diagnosis of peritoneal metastasis or peritoneal cytology before performing laparotomy on these patients.
BACKGROUND: The prognosis for patients with scirrhous gastric cancer (SGC) is extremely poor. However, the management protocol for this type of cancer has not been well discussed. In this study, we retrospectively evaluated the management of SGC and we introduced a new treatment protocol for SGC. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 1991 and 2001, 58 patients with SGC were treated. Thirty-nine, who underwent gastrectomy, were divided into 3 sub-groups according to peritoneal metastasis (P) and peritoneal washing cytology (CY) status [P(-)/CY(-), P(-)/CY(+), and P(+)/CY(+)]. The survival rates of these 3 sub-groups were compared with patients who did not have a gastrectomy (n=19), retrospectively. From 2002, we started a new treatment protocol for SGC. Laparoscopic diagnosis of P or CY and intraperitoneal chemotherapy (IPC) were performed before performing laparotomy on 10 patients with SGC. RESULTS: The 5-year survival rate of the 19 patients in P(-)/CY(-) was 11.6%. The survival rates of patients with P(-)/CY(+) or patients with P(+)/CY(+) were no different from patients who did not have gastrectomy (pleural effusion or ascites negative). In 10 patients who were treated with the new protocol, 7 with P(-)/CY(-) underwent gastrectomy after IPC and 3 with P(+)/CY(+) underwent repeated IPC. CONCLUSION: Gastrectomy may not have prognostic benefit for patients with SGC with CY(+). Thus, we recommend laparoscopic diagnosis of peritoneal metastasis or peritoneal cytology before performing laparotomy on these patients.
Authors: S Semba; Y Kodama; K Ohnuma; E Mizuuchi; R Masuda; M Yashiro; K Hirakawa; H Yokozaki Journal: Br J Cancer Date: 2009-09-22 Impact factor: 7.640