Tanarat Boonriong1, Niran Kietsiriroje. 1. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery and Physical Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Prince of Songkla University, Thailand. btanarat@ratree.psu.ac.th
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) and the hamstring tendons are commonly used for arthroscopially-assisted anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. PURPOSE: To compare the results of arthroscopically-assisted ACL reconstruction using bone-patellar tendon-bone and hamstring tendons grafts in terms of postoperative knee stability, knee functions and clinical rating scale, and patient satisfaction. HYPOTHESIS: There was no difference in the outcomes of the two grafts. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective non-randomized clinical trial. MATERIAL AND METHOD: Two groups of patients, 45 in the BPTB group and 30 in the hamstring group, were followed for at least one year. RESULTS: The two groups had similar pre-operative data except the hamstring group which had a significantly shorter duration of injury before operation (9.5 versus 18 months, p < 0.05). There was no difference in median pre-operative Lysholm knee score (74 in the BPTB group versus 75 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05) and the post-operative one (95 in the BPTB group versus 99 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05). There was also no difference in the median pre-operative HSS knee score (58 in the BPTB group versus 61 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05). Although there was a statistically significant difference in the median post-operative HSS knee score between the two groups (95 in the BPTB group versus 96 in the hamstring group, p < 0.05), this was not clinically significant since both scores were rated as an excellent result. Both groups had a significantly improved knee stability and knee functions (Lysholm and HSS knee scores). The hamstring group, however, had significantly higher patient satisfaction (88% in the BPTB group versus 93% in the hamstring group, p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: Both the BPTB and the hamstring tendon grafts resulted in significantly improved knee stability and functions with high patient satisfaction. The hamstring tendon group, however, had a significantly better post-operative patient satisfaction (Visual Analog Scale, VAS).
BACKGROUND: The bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) and the hamstring tendons are commonly used for arthroscopially-assisted anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. PURPOSE: To compare the results of arthroscopically-assisted ACL reconstruction using bone-patellar tendon-bone and hamstring tendons grafts in terms of postoperative knee stability, knee functions and clinical rating scale, and patient satisfaction. HYPOTHESIS: There was no difference in the outcomes of the two grafts. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective non-randomized clinical trial. MATERIAL AND METHOD: Two groups of patients, 45 in the BPTB group and 30 in the hamstring group, were followed for at least one year. RESULTS: The two groups had similar pre-operative data except the hamstring group which had a significantly shorter duration of injury before operation (9.5 versus 18 months, p < 0.05). There was no difference in median pre-operative Lysholm knee score (74 in the BPTB group versus 75 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05) and the post-operative one (95 in the BPTB group versus 99 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05). There was also no difference in the median pre-operative HSS knee score (58 in the BPTB group versus 61 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05). Although there was a statistically significant difference in the median post-operative HSS knee score between the two groups (95 in the BPTB group versus 96 in the hamstring group, p < 0.05), this was not clinically significant since both scores were rated as an excellent result. Both groups had a significantly improved knee stability and knee functions (Lysholm and HSS knee scores). The hamstring group, however, had significantly higher patient satisfaction (88% in the BPTB group versus 93% in the hamstring group, p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: Both the BPTB and the hamstring tendon grafts resulted in significantly improved knee stability and functions with high patient satisfaction. The hamstring tendon group, however, had a significantly better post-operative patient satisfaction (Visual Analog Scale, VAS).