OBJECTIVE: To prospectively compare the prevention of tumour recurrence by four intravesical adjuvant administration protocols, and thus elucidate the efficacy of early and high total dose instillations of epirubicin to prevent superficial bladder tumour recurrenceafter transurethral resection of bladder tumour (TURBT). PATIENTS AND METHODS: In all, 69 patients with Ta/T1 bladder cancer were randomly assigned to four intravesical administration protocols: A, delayed instillation (first instillation 7 days after TURBT) and low-dose (30 mg once every 2 weeks, six times): B, early instillation (three instillations before 7 days after TURBT) and low-dose; C, delayed and high-dose (30 mg once weekly 12 times) instillation; D, early and high-dose. The influence of the instillation protocols and tumour characteristics on the probability of recurrence-free survival was examined using Kaplan-Meier analysis and a Cox regression hazard model. RESULTS: The early-instillation and high-dose groups had relatively lower recurrence rates after 6 months (A, 30%; B, 25%; C, one of 12; and D, none) and 1 year (50%, 35%, four of nine and one of eight, respectively). Patients who received 360 mg epirubicin (C and D) had a significantly better recurrence-free survival than those receiving 180 mg (A and B; P = 0.012). Preoperative urine cytology and tumour multiplicity were significantly associated with recurrence. However, multivariate analysis of the risk of recurrence using a Cox proportional hazard model showed that urine cytology (hazard ratio 3.11, 95% confidence interval 1.08-8.94, P = 0.04) and total dose (0.32, 0.11-0.92, P = 0.03) were independent prognostic factors for recurrence. CONCLUSION: Patients who received a high-dose epirubicin instillation had a significantly lower recurrence rate but the benefit of early instillation was not confirmed, as the study group was too small.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To prospectively compare the prevention of tumour recurrence by four intravesical adjuvant administration protocols, and thus elucidate the efficacy of early and high total dose instillations of epirubicin to prevent superficial bladder tumour recurrence after transurethral resection of bladder tumour (TURBT). PATIENTS AND METHODS: In all, 69 patients with Ta/T1 bladder cancer were randomly assigned to four intravesical administration protocols: A, delayed instillation (first instillation 7 days after TURBT) and low-dose (30 mg once every 2 weeks, six times): B, early instillation (three instillations before 7 days after TURBT) and low-dose; C, delayed and high-dose (30 mg once weekly 12 times) instillation; D, early and high-dose. The influence of the instillation protocols and tumour characteristics on the probability of recurrence-free survival was examined using Kaplan-Meier analysis and a Cox regression hazard model. RESULTS: The early-instillation and high-dose groups had relatively lower recurrence rates after 6 months (A, 30%; B, 25%; C, one of 12; and D, none) and 1 year (50%, 35%, four of nine and one of eight, respectively). Patients who received 360 mg epirubicin (C and D) had a significantly better recurrence-free survival than those receiving 180 mg (A and B; P = 0.012). Preoperative urine cytology and tumour multiplicity were significantly associated with recurrence. However, multivariate analysis of the risk of recurrence using a Cox proportional hazard model showed that urine cytology (hazard ratio 3.11, 95% confidence interval 1.08-8.94, P = 0.04) and total dose (0.32, 0.11-0.92, P = 0.03) were independent prognostic factors for recurrence. CONCLUSION:Patients who received a high-dose epirubicin instillation had a significantly lower recurrence rate but the benefit of early instillation was not confirmed, as the study group was too small.