Jack H Mydlo1, Brett Lebed. 1. Departmetn of Urology, Temple University School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA 19140, USA. jmydlo@astro.temple.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Sperm banking prior to surgical procedures which may affect fertility, such as retroperitoneal lymph node dissection, has been well documented. However, such procedures are usually performed in young men. With older men marrying later in life, or remarrying, we wanted to investigate the effects of radiation on prostate cancer patients who wanted to have children afterwards. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We encountered several patients with prostate cancer who decided to undergo brachytherapy and were planning to have more children. We performed a search using PubMed and Ovid for the period 1966-2001 using the key words "fertility", "sperm banking", "radiation effects", "prostate cancer" and "brachytherapy". RESULTS: Of the four young patients we encountered who underwent brachytherapy, we found no significant change in semen parameters post-therapy, and three of them were able to father a child subsequently without any deleterious side-effects. It has been demonstrated in several reports that external-beam radiation therapy is associated with decreased spermatogenesis due to Leydig cell dysfunction and decreased serum testosterone, as well as having a direct effect on spermatogonia. However, there is a scarcity of literature discussing the effects of prostate brachytherapy on spermatogenesis as the patients involved are usually older and usually do not desire to father any more children. As I has a half-life of 60 days, we used an exposure of 10 mR/h at the symphysis pubis and used integration to find the total dose exposed to the testis as follows: Limits 14 400 to 0, S 10e (-In2/1440.Tdt) where T = 14 400 and 20.75 R = 20.75 cGy. Therefore, the total dose was 20.75 cGy x 0.91 = 18.88 cGy. This value is considered too low to have any significant effect on testicular tissues. CONCLUSIONS: We speculate that the effects of prostate brachytherapy on spermatogenesis in prostate cancer patients are minimal. However, due to the half-life of I, we recommend that these patients should wait for at least 3-4 months before trying to conceive. Furthermore, younger men with prostate cancer may want to consider sperm banking prior to brachytherapy if they want to have children in the future.
OBJECTIVE: Sperm banking prior to surgical procedures which may affect fertility, such as retroperitoneal lymph node dissection, has been well documented. However, such procedures are usually performed in young men. With older men marrying later in life, or remarrying, we wanted to investigate the effects of radiation on prostate cancerpatients who wanted to have children afterwards. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We encountered several patients with prostate cancer who decided to undergo brachytherapy and were planning to have more children. We performed a search using PubMed and Ovid for the period 1966-2001 using the key words "fertility", "sperm banking", "radiation effects", "prostate cancer" and "brachytherapy". RESULTS: Of the four young patients we encountered who underwent brachytherapy, we found no significant change in semen parameters post-therapy, and three of them were able to father a child subsequently without any deleterious side-effects. It has been demonstrated in several reports that external-beam radiation therapy is associated with decreased spermatogenesis due to Leydig cell dysfunction and decreased serum testosterone, as well as having a direct effect on spermatogonia. However, there is a scarcity of literature discussing the effects of prostate brachytherapy on spermatogenesis as the patients involved are usually older and usually do not desire to father any more children. As I has a half-life of 60 days, we used an exposure of 10 mR/h at the symphysis pubis and used integration to find the total dose exposed to the testis as follows: Limits 14 400 to 0, S 10e (-In2/1440.Tdt) where T = 14 400 and 20.75 R = 20.75 cGy. Therefore, the total dose was 20.75 cGy x 0.91 = 18.88 cGy. This value is considered too low to have any significant effect on testicular tissues. CONCLUSIONS: We speculate that the effects of prostate brachytherapy on spermatogenesis in prostate cancerpatients are minimal. However, due to the half-life of I, we recommend that these patients should wait for at least 3-4 months before trying to conceive. Furthermore, younger men with prostate cancer may want to consider sperm banking prior to brachytherapy if they want to have children in the future.
Authors: Whoon Jong Kil; Romaine C Nichols; Bradford S Hoppe; Christopher G Morris; Robert B Marcus; William Mendenhall; Nancy P Mendenhall; Zuofeng Li; Joseph A Costa; Christopher R Williams; Randal H Henderson Journal: Acta Oncol Date: 2013-04 Impact factor: 4.089