Anita Roy1, Maen Tayeb, Suzie Al-Khogeer. 1. Department of Pediatric Surgery, Maternity and Children's Hospital, PO Box 2595, Dammam 31176, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. anitaroysa@hotmail.com
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate and compare the outcome of newborns with definite (Bells stage II) and advanced (Bells stage III) necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) and to assess the role of primary peritoneal drainage. METHODS: This study was conducted in the Department of Pediatric Surgery, Maternity and Children's Hospital, Dammam, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Medical records of all cases diagnosed with NEC or suspected NEC between May 1993 and June 2003 were reviewed retrospectively. A total of 67 cases meeting the criteria for Modified Bells stage II and III disease were selected for the study. Twenty-five (37%) cases were treated medically and 42 (63%) needed surgical intervention, namely primary peritoneal drainage (PPD) with or without salvage laparotomy (SL) (n=25), or primary laparotomy (PL) (n=17). Data regarding patient demographics, neonatal history, clinical presentation, laboratory and radiological features, operative findings, complications and mortality were collected and compared between the medical and surgical group and between the 2 surgical groups. RESULTS: The overall mortality was 37%, 8% in the medical group versus 55% in the surgically treated group. The PPD group had the highest mortality (72%) versus 29% in the PL group. In the PPD group, 14 (56%) needed SL and only 3 (12%) survived without laparotomy. The mean gestational age and birthweight were 32.1 weeks and 1713 gms in the PPD group as compared to 35.7 weeks and 2484 gms in the PL group. The PPD group were more critically sick than the PL group. The average length of time from onset to laparotomy was longer, 6.6 days in the PPD group versus 2.2 days in the PL group. In the 31 cases undergoing laparotomy, the terminal ileum was involved most frequently followed by the cecum and right colon. The PPD + SL group had a higher mortality in isolated, multifocal, and pan involvement of bowel when compared to the PL group. All babies with only isolated involvement in the PL group survived. CONCLUSION: The surgical mortality of NEC in our hospital is very high due to advanced disease. The PPD group in our study fared badly, as it comprised a poor risk group with ongoing sepsis, with the bias being in favor of PPD as these babies were unfit to undergo major surgery. Early SL after PPD in those showing signs of persistent disease may improve the outcome in this group.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate and compare the outcome of newborns with definite (Bells stage II) and advanced (Bells stage III) necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) and to assess the role of primary peritoneal drainage. METHODS: This study was conducted in the Department of Pediatric Surgery, Maternity and Children's Hospital, Dammam, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Medical records of all cases diagnosed with NEC or suspected NEC between May 1993 and June 2003 were reviewed retrospectively. A total of 67 cases meeting the criteria for Modified Bells stage II and III disease were selected for the study. Twenty-five (37%) cases were treated medically and 42 (63%) needed surgical intervention, namely primary peritoneal drainage (PPD) with or without salvage laparotomy (SL) (n=25), or primary laparotomy (PL) (n=17). Data regarding patient demographics, neonatal history, clinical presentation, laboratory and radiological features, operative findings, complications and mortality were collected and compared between the medical and surgical group and between the 2 surgical groups. RESULTS: The overall mortality was 37%, 8% in the medical group versus 55% in the surgically treated group. The PPD group had the highest mortality (72%) versus 29% in the PL group. In the PPD group, 14 (56%) needed SL and only 3 (12%) survived without laparotomy. The mean gestational age and birthweight were 32.1 weeks and 1713 gms in the PPD group as compared to 35.7 weeks and 2484 gms in the PL group. The PPD group were more critically sick than the PL group. The average length of time from onset to laparotomy was longer, 6.6 days in the PPD group versus 2.2 days in the PL group. In the 31 cases undergoing laparotomy, the terminal ileum was involved most frequently followed by the cecum and right colon. The PPD + SL group had a higher mortality in isolated, multifocal, and pan involvement of bowel when compared to the PL group. All babies with only isolated involvement in the PL group survived. CONCLUSION: The surgical mortality of NEC in our hospital is very high due to advanced disease. The PPD group in our study fared badly, as it comprised a poor risk group with ongoing sepsis, with the bias being in favor of PPD as these babies were unfit to undergo major surgery. Early SL after PPD in those showing signs of persistent disease may improve the outcome in this group.