BACKGROUND: This study was designed to measure inter-observer variation between thoracic radiologists in the diagnosis of diffuse parenchymal lung disease (DPLD) using high resolution computed tomography (HRCT) and to identify areas of difficulty where expertise, in the form of national panels, would be of particular value. METHODS: HRCT images of 131 patients with DPLD (from a tertiary referral hospital (n = 66) and regional teaching centres (n = 65)) were reviewed by 11 thoracic radiologists. Inter-observer variation for the first choice diagnosis was quantified using the unadjusted kappa coefficient of agreement. Observers stated differential diagnoses and assigned a percentage likelihood to each. A weighted kappa was calculated for the likelihood of each of the six most frequently diagnosed disease entities. RESULTS: Observer agreement on the first choice diagnosis was moderate for the entire cohort (kappa = 0.48) and was higher for cases from regional centres (kappa = 0.60) than for cases from the tertiary referral centre (kappa = 0.34). 62% of cases from regional teaching centres were diagnosed with high confidence and good observer agreement (kappa = 0.77). Non-specific interstitial pneumonia (NSIP) was in the differential diagnosis in most disagreements (55%). Weighted kappa values quantifying the likelihood of specific diseases were moderate to good (mean 0.57, range 0.49-0.70). CONCLUSION: There is good agreement between thoracic radiologists for the HRCT diagnosis of DPLD encountered in regional teaching centres. However, cases diagnosed with low confidence, particularly where NSIP is considered as a differential diagnosis, may benefit from the expertise of a reference panel.
BACKGROUND: This study was designed to measure inter-observer variation between thoracic radiologists in the diagnosis of diffuse parenchymal lung disease (DPLD) using high resolution computed tomography (HRCT) and to identify areas of difficulty where expertise, in the form of national panels, would be of particular value. METHODS: HRCT images of 131 patients with DPLD (from a tertiary referral hospital (n = 66) and regional teaching centres (n = 65)) were reviewed by 11 thoracic radiologists. Inter-observer variation for the first choice diagnosis was quantified using the unadjusted kappa coefficient of agreement. Observers stated differential diagnoses and assigned a percentage likelihood to each. A weighted kappa was calculated for the likelihood of each of the six most frequently diagnosed disease entities. RESULTS: Observer agreement on the first choice diagnosis was moderate for the entire cohort (kappa = 0.48) and was higher for cases from regional centres (kappa = 0.60) than for cases from the tertiary referral centre (kappa = 0.34). 62% of cases from regional teaching centres were diagnosed with high confidence and good observer agreement (kappa = 0.77). Non-specific interstitial pneumonia (NSIP) was in the differential diagnosis in most disagreements (55%). Weighted kappa values quantifying the likelihood of specific diseases were moderate to good (mean 0.57, range 0.49-0.70). CONCLUSION: There is good agreement between thoracic radiologists for the HRCT diagnosis of DPLD encountered in regional teaching centres. However, cases diagnosed with low confidence, particularly where NSIP is considered as a differential diagnosis, may benefit from the expertise of a reference panel.
Authors: P Soler; A Bergeron; M Kambouchner; O Groussard; M Brauner; P Grenier; B Crestani; H Mal; A Tazi; J P Battesti; P Loiseau; D Valeyre Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 2000-07 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: T E Hartman; S J Swensen; D M Hansell; T V Colby; J L Myers; H D Tazelaar; A G Nicholson; A U Wells; J H Ryu; D E Midthun; R M du Bois; N L Müller Journal: Radiology Date: 2000-12 Impact factor: 11.105
Authors: Nicholas J Screaton; Fiona N A C Miller; Bipen D Patel; Ashley Groves; Angela D Tasker; David A Lomas; Christopher D R Flower Journal: Eur Radiol Date: 2010-08-24 Impact factor: 5.315
Authors: Alexandra R Cunliffe; Samuel G Armato; Christopher Straus; Renuka Malik; Hania A Al-Hallaq Journal: Phys Med Biol Date: 2014-08-26 Impact factor: 3.609
Authors: Simon L F Walsh; Toby M Maher; Martin Kolb; Venerino Poletti; Richard Nusser; Luca Richeldi; Carlo Vancheri; Margaret L Wilsher; Katerina M Antoniou; Jüergen Behr; Elisabeth Bendstrup; Kevin Brown; Lucio Calandriello; Tamera J Corte; Vincent Cottin; Bruno Crestani; Kevin Flaherty; Ian Glaspole; Jan Grutters; Yoshikazu Inoue; Maria Kokosi; Yasuhiro Kondoh; Vasileios Kouranos; Michael Kreuter; Kerri Johannson; Eoin Judge; Brett Ley; George Margaritopoulos; Fernando J Martinez; Maria Molina-Molina; António Morais; Hilario Nunes; Ganesh Raghu; Christopher J Ryerson; Moises Selman; Paolo Spagnolo; Hiroyuki Taniguchi; Sara Tomassetti; Dominique Valeyre; Marlies Wijsenbeek; Wim Wuyts; David Hansell; Athol Wells Journal: Eur Respir J Date: 2017-08-31 Impact factor: 16.671
Authors: Hanaa Al-Khawari; Reji P Athyal; Osama Al-Saeed; Prio N Sada; Sana Al-Muthairi; Adel Al-Awadhi Journal: Ann Saudi Med Date: 2010 Mar-Apr Impact factor: 1.526